Pod G4 vs Pod Mini

[Eternal Snow]

heys alls~

haven't been here to the forums for quite a long time now so you can sort of say i'm new here~ hehe~

anyways, i'm sure this topic has been brought up a number of times but yah, hope that you'll bear with me while i explain the situation i have here~ LoL~ have been pondering about this for a couple of weeks now~

details:

Pod G4 - S$550 - 20 gig - quite large in my opinion
Pod Mini - S$450 - 4 gig - decent size

what i'm looking for in the players is basically that i have enough space and that it's size is not too large~

abit of a background information just in case~

over here, there's this brand called Creative~ Creative is a well established local brand that has a player which is quite simiar to pod and have better functions and is more economical, but i simply do not like the design~ however, it has this player called Muvo N200 which is about 2mm more in thickness as compared to a pod shuffle and only 1/2 the length of the shuffle at the cost of about S$250 but only has 1 gig of space~ i thought of getting it because it's small and has the recording function built in, but it's LCD screen is just too small to scroll through multiple songs~ i have to look at the track names to find the songs~

bonuses:

1) have recording function
2) have enough space
(i have about 1 gig of legal mp3s in my comp but i also have a number of cds (about 20+) which i might want to load inside~ not to mention other songs which may come in later)
3) reasonable price
(not that i place emphasis on this but looking at the price above you sort of can't help but think about it)

uses:

1) while studying
2) traveling
3) while hanging out

hope you all can help me out~

[deejay]

I prefer the 20GB because it can also be used to backup data..

But personally..i perfer iRiver mp3 players ^^

[Eternal Snow]

i used to like iRiver alot too, until my mp3 discman went dead in less than a year~

[Mokona]

I have a 20gb iPod... i love it!

[Lindy]

Creative have been making MP3 and audio devices for FAR longer than Apple, and they're far better at it.

Not only are Creative devices cheaper, support more audio formats and have greater storage capacity, they're also no Apple products and that boosts them by a million times as well >_>

Don't buy either.

Buy a Creative product, maybe a MuVo, or the MuVo X-Trainer is pretty good, though I have a 30gb Nomad ZenNX, which while being about a year or so old now, is still awesomely good.

If you want to waste your money and go for something new and up to date, get a Creative Zen Micro, which is about 5gigs I think, and they come in a variety of colours. In fact, they generally look a lot nicer than iPods too.

But don't fall for the idea that iPods are the only high storage MP3 players out there, there's more companies and products available than I'd care to count.

[Eternal Snow]

if Creative comes into the picture, i probably won't choose zen micro, on the basis that based on my preference, i don't quite like the design of the zen micro~ if Creative's zen micro looked somewhat more plain or close to a pod, i would have bought it immediately~ no offense Creative supporters~

as for price, i don't quite mind the cost~ however, in the end i must like what i got~ i feel that is more impt than anything~ cause if you love it, you'll treasure it~

[Leeza]

Whoa, I agree with Lindy! iPod is all about image and looks.

Also, iPod has an internal battery, which is not replacable. Creative's is replaceable and rechargable.

[Destai]

I "want" an ipod. I'll settle for a mini but if i can save enough Id defitely get a 20gb or higher.

[Brian The Pink Shark]

i got a 20 gig one and it is really good, personnaly i dont like the design of the mini ipod, but it really depends on how big your music collection is,

[Eternal Snow]

Creative have been making MP3 and audio devices for FAR longer than Apple, and they're far better at it.

Not only are Creative devices cheaper, support more audio formats and have greater storage capacity, they're also no Apple products and that boosts them by a million times as well >_>

Don't buy either.

Buy a Creative product, maybe a MuVo, or the MuVo X-Trainer is pretty good, though I have a 30gb Nomad ZenNX, which while being about a year or so old now, is still awesomely good.

If you want to waste your money and go for something new and up to date, get a Creative Zen Micro, which is about 5gigs I think, and they come in a variety of colours. In fact, they generally look a lot nicer than iPods too.

But don't fall for the idea that iPods are the only high storage MP3 players out there, there's more companies and products available than I'd care to count.

hmm, just adding~ i don't really want a pod cause of it's high storage~ but because i really really really like the scroll system which is easier than a zen~ tried both before so yah~

Whoa, I agree with Lindy! iPod is all about image and looks.

Also, iPod has an internal battery, which is not replacable. Creative's is replaceable and rechargable.

i've always felt that something that looks gd plays a part in whether you'll treasure it or not~ (unless it's given of course, that's a diff case) but come to think of it, yah there'll be battery problems~ thanks for bringing it up~ will ponder on it~

thanks too to the rest for their views~ feel free to provide more as i won't be getting it within the next few days~ maybe next week or so~

[Brian The Pink Shark]

speaking of battery replacement does any one know how much it costs to have it replaced, in £sterling please

[Samuraid]

Buy a Creative product,

Creative >>> all

[Nod]

i have a 20GB Creative Zen Touch mp3 player. it has lots of cool functions (which i dont have time to mention suffice to say you can find out on the creative website), and its battery lasts for 24 hours which is much better than the iPod (i think they only last bout 8hrs). I really like it, tis a little bit thick, but relatively small.

[Lindy]

Apple's batteries cost, from what I've heard somewhere between £50~100, and you have to send it away to get the battery replaced.

For Creative products they cost about £10 or so, depends where you get them from.

Though one thing, when my Nomad broke, I went through the returns process and sent it back, thinking they'd just send me back mine repaired, but instead they just sent me a whole brand new, complete set, new player, box, carry case, battery, leads, EVERYTHING.

I doubt Apple would do the same thing, nor would they re-instate the year warranty on the new product carrying on one year from when you recieved the replacement like Creative do.

[Dr Unne]

http://creative.com/products/product...5&product=4908