I. The new style is now the only style.
C. Quitters: me, Shlup, Yams, Unne(?), perhaps one/two more
Thoughts: I could quit over this, but I probably wouldn't.
II. Borderline swear words added to the filter with continued editing of the filtered edits.
C. Quitters: Shlup, D, kishi(?), at least one more
Thoughts: I could quit over this, but I probably wouldn't.
IIa. Converse of II. Swear filter is disabled and swearing is free game.
C. Quitters: me, Unne, Leeza, one more
Thoughts: I could quit over this and it wouldn't look too weird... but some wouldn't notice.
III. A staff member (me for now) is banned for posting a porn image.
C. Quitters: me (banned), Yams, D, Shlup or 4, basically the staffers closest to the banned member
Thoughts: I can't imagine you posting porn at all and I don't think the members would buy it. Kishi or Shlup are the two obvious choices here. I could quit over this kind of thing.
IIIa. Converse of III. A staff member (me) posts porn and isn't banned for it.
C. Quitters: Dr Unne, Loony BoB, RSL, kishi (think of the uproar THAT would cause)
Thoughts: I can't imagine you posting porn at all and I don't think the members would buy it. Kishi or Shlup are the two obvious choices here. I could quit over this kind of thing. I don't think Kishi would step down over someone not getting banned for posting porn.
I still think we should definitely include the idea of banning and unbanning an account in a clear power struggle (likely ed) and then having the new staff remove Feedback and whatnot, as in my other post. It's the idea I think would be most believable by both oldbie and newbie alike, and it would show a clear power struggle which is most important. If we did go with the porn idea, I think we should 'ban', unban-and-knight and then 'ban' Kishi again. Or something.
The power struggle, the banning of a member and the removal of Feedback are the main things I think would make for a huge uproar, collectively.
