Quote Originally Posted by sayen
in the game cloud said that nibhelhime is his hometown and in the true flash back sephiroth is talking to cloud not zack pluss tifa rembers grwoing up with him in that town
Yes, that was my point. Nibelheim was Cloud's hometown, just as he claimed. He didn't claim Zack's entire past, which would have included Gongaga, so it's unlikely that he claimed his birthdate. For that matter, if August 19 were Zack's birthdate, the Advent Children website would tell us as much if it were bearing the correct information concerning Cloud and Zack.