The original Resident Evil game was definitely the best with its multiple endings. Great replayability. RE2 is the second best, I'd say, with RE3 coming last.

I haven't got a GameCube, so I never got to try out RE4 or the RE remakes, for that matter. I do have the PS2 version of RE: Code Veronica X. While that's a rather nice game in itself, it's still not exactly world breaking. RE1 pwns j00 all~

I'm still looking forward to the PS2 version of RE4. *can't wait* x_x