Quote Originally Posted by Lindy
Neither, they're both overhyped piles of tripe.

Both Rowling and Pullman have awfully simplistic writing styles, and their narratives just don't flow together. Combine that with boring, unlikeable characters and generally stupid plots, they're the kind of books that would turn me off reading ANYTHING.

Both sereii recieve far too much praise for what they are, I mean, there ARE actually other books out there, shock horror, you don't have to read Harry Potter just because everyone else is. The same thing happened with The Da Vinci Code, it's stupid.
exactly my words.