I got S4 and beat it through once, obtaining all 108 stars. When I tried getting all of them again in a new game, I could not get Bartholomew (in Nay-Kobold) to join me, and Maxine would show up way earlier than for her time (the time you should be able to get Bartholomew). I have tried 6 more times, with new games, and I have failed to get all of the stars. Has anyone heard of this? And if anyone could possibly help me with this, it would be great!