Here's my other predictions using Psy's idea. And thanks for the title change.

1) Best Member
Proto's Prediction: Del Murder
Also likely to do well: Loony BoB
Watch out for: The Captain

2) Best Male
Proto's Prediction: Psychotic
Also likely to do well: Loony BoB
Watch out for: The Captain

3) Best Female
Proto's Prediction: Monkey
Also likely to do well: Iri Valentine
Watch out for: fire_of_avalon

4) Best Administrator
Proto's Prediction: Loony BoB
Also likely to do well: cl_out
Watch out for: Roogle

5) Best Cid's Knight
Proto's Prediction: Kawaii Ryűkishi
Also likely to do well: Leeza
Watch out for: eestlinc

6) Best Site Staff
Proto's Prediction: theundeadhero
Also likely to do well: Flying Mullet
Watch out for: Samuraid

7) Best Recognized Member / Former Staff
Proto's Prediction: Agent Proto
Also likely to do well: Monkey
Watch out for: TheAbominatrix

8) Best Veteran
Proto's Prediction: The Captain
Also likely to do well: Necronopticous
Watch out for: Psychotic

9) Best Regular
Proto's Prediction: Iri Valentine
Also likely to do well: boris no no
Watch out for: crash26821

10) Best Newbie
Proto's Prediction: SNOOZER
Also likely to do well: Caspian
Watch out for: The Jamie Star Scenario

11) Nicest Member
Proto's Prediction: The Captain
Also likely to do well: Leeza
Watch out for: Xander

12) Evilest Member
Proto's Prediction: Lindy
Also likely to do well: Meat Puppet
Watch out for: Leeza

13) Sexiest Male
Proto's Prediction: Sexy McAwesome
Also likely to do well: DMKA
Watch out for: Necronopticous

14) Sexiest Female
Proto's Prediction: boris no no
Also likely to do well: Iri Valentine
Watch out for: ShlupQuack

15) Cutest Male
Proto's Prediction: Loony BoB
Also likely to do well: Psychotic
Watch out for: Seeby See~

16) Cutest Female
Proto's Prediction: Chaos
Also likely to do well: Rye
Watch out for: Iri Valentine

17) Best Custom Rank
Proto's Prediction: Old Manus
Also likely to do well: Spuuky
Watch out for: Psychotic

18) Best Avatar
Proto's Prediction: Del Murder
Also likely to do well: Yamaneko
Watch out for: Old Manus

19) Best Signature
Proto's Prediction: Del Murder
Also likely to do well: Award Guy
Watch out for: Rye

20) Best Artist
Proto's Prediction: black orb
Also likely to do well: Iri Valentine
Watch out for: Agent Proto

21) Best Graphic Designer
Proto's Prediction: Rye
Also likely to do well: Xander
Watch out for: ~yunie~

22) Best Writer
Proto's Prediction: Strider
Also likely to do well: Dkings'queen
Watch out for: Necronopticous

23) Best Poet
Proto's Prediction: eestlinc
Also likely to do well: nik0tine
Watch out for: Jack

24) Best Poster
Proto's Prediction: Big D
Also likely to do well: The Captain
Watch out for: Psychotic

25) Best Spammer
Proto's Prediction: Psychotic
Also likely to do well: Del Murder
Watch out for: -N-

26) Best Chatter
Proto's Prediction: Walker Texas Ranger
Also likely to do well: fire_of_avalon
Watch out for: Denmark

27) Funniest Member
Proto's Prediction: Not At All Reno
Also likely to do well: Del Murder
Watch out for: Meat Puppet

28) Weirdest Member
Proto's Prediction: Chris
Also likely to do well: Meat Puppet
Watch out for: Quina

29) Horniest Member
Proto's Prediction: Fuzakeru
Also likely to do well: Ansem
Watch out for: Joel

30) Most Underrated Member
Proto's Prediction: -N-
Also likely to do well: Hsu
Watch out for: Necronopticous

31) Most Missed Member
Proto's Prediction: ff babe
Also likely to do well: Baloki
Watch out for: Dr Unne

32) Most Helpful Gamer
Proto's Prediction: Kawaii Ryűkishi
Also likely to do well: Sephiroth1999AD
Watch out for: Joel

33) Most Helpful Techy
Proto's Prediction: cl_out
Also likely to do well: Samuraid
Watch out for: Yamaneko

34) Most Helpful Member
Proto's Prediction: Loony BoB
Also likely to do well: Big D
Watch out for: Leeza

35) Cutest Couple
Proto's Prediction: Calliope & Spuuky
Also likely to do well: Lindy & Xander
Watch out for: Fuzakeru & ShiggtyLuffLuff

Most Likely To…

36) Become a Cid's Knight
Proto's Prediction: crash26821
Also likely to do well: The Captain
Watch out for: Sepho

37) Get Banned
Proto's Prediction: The Redneck
Also likely to do well: DMKA
Watch out for: Agent Proto

38) Be God
Proto's Prediction: Cid
Also likely to do well: Kawaii Ryűkishi
Watch out for: Jebus

39) Be Satan
Proto's Prediction: Bert
Also likely to do well: Lindy
Watch out for: Monkey

40) Be Cid's Illegitimate Child
Proto's Prediction: Award Guy
Also likely to do well: Loony BoB
Watch out for: ShlupQuack

41) Win a Ciddie for the very first time
Proto's Prediction: Jebus
Also likely to do well: Bert
Watch out for: -N-

42) Murder someone for winning the Ciddie they wanted
Proto's Prediction: Joel
Also likely to do well: Bert
Watch out for: Liono, from Thundercats

43) Be a modwhore and get torn apart by an angry mob of pictchfork-wielding members for being a damned filthy modwhore because nobody likes a modwhore
Proto's Prediction: Agent Proto
Also likely to do well: Ultima Shadow
Watch out for: MecaKane

44) Spend the rest of their life playing FFXI
Proto's Prediction: Mikztsu
Also likely to do well: Citizen Bleys
Watch out for: UltimateSpamGrover

45) Get hit by a bus
Proto's Prediction: Joel
Also likely to do well: Psychotic
Watch out for: The Redneck

46) Be driving the bus
Proto's Prediction: Psychotic
Also likely to do well: Wyllius
Watch out for: Loony BoB

47) Spend hours searching for the lyrics to The Cosby Show Theme Song
Proto's Prediction: Little Miss Awesome
Also likely to do well: Chris
Watch out for: theundeadhero

48) Be Fighter
Proto's Prediction: Fighter
Also likely to do well: DJZen
Watch out for: Joel

49) Be Black Mage
Proto's Prediction: Black Mage
Also likely to do well: Iri Valentine
Watch out for: Behold the Void

50) Get Together
Proto's Prediction: Joel & MecaKane
Also likely to do well: Del Snizz & Walker Texas Ranger
Watch out for: Award Guy & Election Booth