The chicken, obviously, because eggs don't have legs (except sheldon and dixie, but they're FREAKS!)
I still voted for the egg though (you have to give the little guy some encouragement...) not to mention that a chicken couldn't just have been created out of thin air, but a mutant may have popped out of something else... I think (although nobody really realises it yet) that this poll is just separating the religious from the non-religious and so far, it has just proven that 52.94% of Final Fantasy players aren't religious (or are but just prefer science and cold logic...)