It'd be nice if Billy put out some more nice grungy, American rock, but I can see this being another spade of faggoty lovesongs with a bunch of people I don't know. That early 90's grunge band is gone, and unless they really manage to pull out some rock like they used (not the same, to clarify, but in the spirit of, if nothing else) it won't really be the Pumpkins no matter who's in the line-up, it'll be Billy Corgan being "zany", "introspective" and "experimental".

Having said that, with Billy (and Melissa) being off doing all these more easy-going things for so long, James doing a more Nu-metal thing with APC, Jimmy doing his solo thing and D'arcy probably standing on street corners, I can't help but hope if it does happen they go back to their roots, at least a little.