Sense is not being made here. How are right to property and right to life the same thing at all? Last I checked, the right to property and the right to life are two completely different items, and one of them is guaranteed by the Declaration of Independence, and one is not.

And how is it stealing to tax rich people so that people who can't afford medical treatment can continue to live? If taxing the masses is not theft, then I don't see how a "life tax" would qualify as stealing.

It sounds to me like what you two are arguing is because a few rich people don't want to pay the miniscule amount of money it would take to keep poor people with AIDS alive, those people don't deserve to be allowed to live. Is that what you're arguing? If so, come right out and admit it.