Which of these theories fit better the storyline?

[Christmas]

BTW, since this is a poll then it the majority of the votes that matters right?

And the Majority of the vote goes to Laguna and Raine are Squall's father......parents.

But are you going to prove that what the public or the majority of the voters that what they believe in are wrong?

[Discord]

Has Square ever officially confiremed anything? Like the R=U was said to be a lie, but not officially. I don't think that they would do anything like that, for various reasons, plus maybe it was though of as a twist that was not ment to be answered. You know, Steven King has a bunch of those and when the fans ask him, he just says:"I don't have a bloody clue"

[Alexander]

Laguna and Raine are Squall's parents. Because the others are TOTALLY IDIOT. o.o

[Abraxas]

This poll should not include the fourth option.
I think it doesn't negate or support any of the other three.... besides, I believe everyoone agrees that the fourth is more than accepted and obviously suggested by the game itself.

[Ohhh]

laguna and raine are his parents and i like to believe ult is rinoa, even if it isnt true, it would make sense if it was.. thus that is what i believe

[Lenna]

Gawd It's so smurfing obvious that Raine and Laguna are Squall's parents, not to mention that his place of Birth was WinHill. Where you go and see Raine & Laguna together for the first time. And to be honest do you actually ever see anyone else calling Ellone "Sis" during the game other than when Squall says "oh we called her sis because she was the oldest of the lot". You only see him saying Sis when they were all little if I'm correct. And yes when she does that taking them into the past thing she always puts Squall into Laguna's body.

This is just like saying Rinoa's mum isn't Julia. *rolls eyes*

Soooooooooo I'm sorry but this isn't classed as a "theory" therefore is practically off topic ;o

[Dreddz]

None

[Future Esthar]

Has Square ever officially confiremed anything? Like the R=U was said to be a lie, but not officially. I don't think that they would do anything like that, for various reasons, plus maybe it was though of as a twist that was not ment to be answered. You know, Steven King has a bunch of those and when the fans ask him, he just says:"I don't have a bloody clue"

Exactly my point.
Maybe Square even don´t confirm it.
It could be a lie from the person who told it.
__________________

[Destai]

No its pretty clear that Raine had a child younger than Ellone and died hence that child was shipped to an orphanage and grew up there. That child bein practically confirmed Lagunas in the ending. The child is younger than Ellone like the rest of the kids from the orphanage. Then theres the references like Laguna holding Squalls card. Laguna, Raine and Squalls name all having a water reference. Then take into account how Ellone has a particular interest in Squall who if the theory is correct is the son of the closest thing Ellone has/had to parents. Plus Kiros says you look like your father to Squall, hence Kiros knows Squalls father and Laguna says he wants to have an important discussion after everythings calmed down. Why is this different to R=U or the usual smut/theories for FFVIII on these boards? Because the game actually goes out on a limb to suggest the theory is true.

And last I heard Autumn Rain had a magazine with a letter from Square proving the R=U theory false.

[Christmas]

Exactly my point.
Maybe Square even don´t confirm it
It could be a lie from the person who told

It also doesn't say the others are right either since Square didn't confirm the other theories and even so they can be also be lies since the game events and scripts are already full of lies pointed out by you.

And no, it does not link to your theories.Since Square can lie about the L+R=S theory, your other theories is also hidden by Square like what you did with the last poll. I can also say that your theories is also lies since there is already so much lying going around here and there.

This L+R=S theory is supported by several in game events and strong hints which is pointed out by others and the majority of the people catch the hint which reflected on the result of your poll.

Only a minority of the people think that Ulti is actually Edea but I am not saying it wrong either since this is a poll, we go for the majority. The majority voted "4" so which mean most of the public believed in that which mean the verdict.

And if you wanted to convince others the others there is something more than meets the eyes, let's just say the poll result reflect what they think and not what you want them to think.

[Xaven]

Wait. You said that Julia=Edea=Ultimecia. Why did you seperate them out in your poll (soon to be theory thread)?

Oh, I vote the fourth choice as it is by far the most hinted at (and makes the most sense) of the selection.

[boys from the dwarf]

the bottom one because its the only true one.(apart from where youve put raine is sqalls father.)

[vivi-forever]

The ownly one i think is true is R+L=S although i like the idea of R=U it is impossoble, but i am trying to get myself to beleave it is true because i like the idea.

[boys from the dwarf]

The ownly one i think is true is R+L=S although i like the idea of R=U it is impossoble, but i am trying to get myself to beleave it is true because i like the idea.

the r=u theory is what evidence that is actually true proves it?its anice theory but i not true.

[Future Esthar]

Hope reddragon was not being sarcastic.

I was a proponent of L+R=S until yesterday.
Today I noted that Squall could be Irvine+Selphie´s son.

Ulti=Edea and Ulti=Julia was separated because the demonstrations were different.