A Theory...

[Skyblade]

So, you're saying you think Ellone = Ultimecia simply because you can't imagine Ultimecia using a machine to get to the past with? Sorry, but that won't hold at all. Your personal opinion on one tiny little factor of the plot does not amount to a plausible theory.

And you said every theory is right until we find the truth. That's wrong. If I were to say that Squalls parents are a Chocobo and an Esthar Guard, am I supposed to be considered right? Of course not. A theory can only be considered possible if it is first made plausible. That's why we embrace the 'theory' that Laguna and Raine are Squalls parents; it's made VERY plausible.

Oh, and I still think you're Future Esthar I'm afraid.

Actually, his theory doesn't hold up to the game at all. Even if Ulti was Ellone, she'd still have to use the machine to go back in time. Ellone can only send back other people. She can even communicate with the others that she sends back, but she can't send herself back.

I still agree, and I still pray that it is true. One Future Esthar is enough.

[sparkie]

Nah, Future Esthar's grammar is worse. And I dunno, does FE use the word "her"?

But if it is him it's obviously a little experiment on his part to see if we would believe him because we don't see Future Esthar as the poster and have prejudgements. Weeeak.


How bout this for a theory: Everyone is who the game says they are.

I like it.

[Christmas]

theories are always the right ones until we found the truth since it's a THEORY

Is this what Future Esthar said about his theories too?

i really don't see Ultimecia pressing buttons on a machine

Maybe we also dun see Ultimecia's servants chanting evil curse and prayers to seal your powers while you are in their castle but your powers is still sealed. Just for references, this is something like what was said in the past:

Look,many of the things said here were events that the game don´t show.The game don´t show Julia dying neither

But the game tell us she is dead.

and Ellone wanted to change the past...

I remember it being told in the game.

Ellone: Of course! You were my eyes. Thanks to you guys, I was able to
see how much I was loved. I couldn't change the past but just seeing it
was more than enough. Thank you so much.

Squall: It's ok. I came here because I need your help. You said you
can't change the past, right?

[sparkie]

Maybe it's Future Esthar's "brother". They do seem to think alike. :rolleyes2


Btw, welcome back Unknowns!

[Skyblade]

No, it's Future Esthar. Has anyone else noticed that despite titles like "A clue, perhaps", and "A theory" (which would normally draw Future Esthar to them like a moth to the flame), Future Esthar has yet to post in either of this guy's threads? Or that this guy has yet to post in any of Future Esthar's? Coincidence? I think not...

[Discord]

Just ask one of the Cid's Knights to do an IP Check

[Skyblade]

Just ask one of the Cid's Knights to do an IP Check

Different IP doesn't mean a different poster. I could set up accounts on my computer, my dad's computer, my mom's computer... It's not that hard to fool an IP check.

[Christmas]

Different IP doesn't mean a different poster. I could set up accounts on my computer, my dad's computer, my mom's computer... It's not that hard to fool an IP check.

Let's not jump to conclusion here......being wrongly accused is very sad.....

Btw, welcome back Unknowns!

Thanks, nice to see you again

[Skyblade]

Different IP doesn't mean a different poster. I could set up accounts on my computer, my dad's computer, my mom's computer... It's not that hard to fool an IP check.

Let's not jump to conclusion here......being wrongly accused is very sad.....

True. Especially if you are wrongly accused as being Future Esthar. But please, let me believe this, for the sake of my sanity. If these two are seperate people, and they combined their "logic" to form a single theory...

NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

[Christmas]

If these two are seperate people, and they combined their "logic" to form a single theory...

If they do, there is not much we can do about it since they had the right to post what they want here and only be removed if the moderators think it is just insane....

But currently I dun see there is much linkage with the theories the two of them.

The similarities I see is that those two tend to overanaylsis and think that almost every minor details in the game might lead to something big.

[Discord]

Different IP doesn't mean a different poster. I could set up accounts on my computer, my dad's computer, my mom's computer... It's not that hard to fool an IP check.

Let's not jump to conclusion here......being wrongly accused is very sad.....

True. Especially if you are wrongly accused as being Future Esthar. But please, let me believe this, for the sake of my sanity. If these two are seperate people, and they combined their "logic" to form a single theory...

NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

Yup! Just what I wanted to say. It wouldn't be nice if someone new gets on the forums and suddenly get accused that he is somebody else whom he doesn't even know. That doesn't give you a very good of the community.

As for the IP check, your right, but most people don't start running IP cloaking or using different computers unless they really really want to hide their identity and thus the IP check is a pretty effective weapon against double accounts.

And yeah: Hi Unknowns