I find RE2 lame now. Ive played through it several times, and I have no incentive to play it again on PS1 ever again. It's just too short and boring to me.

I would say Silent Hill. It's really long, one hell of a challenge even with the secret weapons on Hard Mode, and it's bloody scary. The biggest fright I had from playing it was the possessed school, in the locker room (You know what im talking about, those who got to that point.) I would it again any time. The last location is really cool, especially how you have no map. When I played the demo, I instantly wanted this game. The demo was great, it wsnt some cheap one small level demo, it was the whole school, although different from the actual game.

Like Cookieface, I think Silent Hill is much better than the other three. SH2 didnt really scare me, but I enjoyed it nonetheless. SH3 is bloody scary, even with the Unlimited Sub-Machine Gun and Lightsaber, I get butterflies when playing it. SH4 was not scary, and sort of lame, but the Hospital, that room with the moaning gave the biggest fright ive ever had, because since the camera shows a hole, I ran right into the room, only to have the camera turn around, and ARGGHHHHHHHH! (You who have seen it know what I mean, right?) The apartment getting the occasional Demonic Incursion was damn cool too.

I enjoyed Resident Evil 3 to some extent, but it was too short, and didnt live up to what I had heard and read about it. If RE games were a lot longer, as in Silent Hill 1 length, I would feel more inclined to play them. RE4 is great, but i need to REALLY concentrate on it.