I flipping hated Even In Death up until I heard it performed acoustically on the radio. Holy crap is that an amazing piece of music when there's not so many annoying noises going on.

I really enjoy some of the older Evanescence, but a lot of it is really horrible too. I much prefer their polished versions of My Immortal, Whisper, Missing, etc... as far as favorites go, I really liked Before the Dawn. It's a really different sound for them, very romantic, and I like it.

Lastly, grrr, You is not an Evanescence song.