Quote Originally Posted by Treize
sorry to tell u guys this but the least possble # is 1 because theres more then 1 dimoned(i cant spell good) in the chest to start with so thats the least possble # i think?
Nope.

It says they throw the extra diamond overboard. If there was 1 diamond and it was discarded by Pirate 1, then what would Pirates 2, 3, 4, 5 throw overboard? It says they all throw 1 extra diamond overboard.