KOTOR or KOTOR II

[Tempest]

The characters, even the dialogue, were/was a lot deeper in KOTOR 2. And you didn't have just one romance option like in KOTOR 1, you could have up to three.

I guess you were playing male Exile. I never finished male Exile playthrough. The romance is almost non-existent as the female Exile, except the fights between Atton and Di. All the other stuff was cut. But, you gotta admit, the romance with Carth or Bastila is a lot better.

The characters are very deep in KotoR 2, it's just a shame there wasn't any sidequest for them like in KotoR 1.

[Captain Maxx Power]

There was way too much cut back from Kotor II that really made it a highly inferior game compared to the one it could have been. Considering that many of the dialogue options and sounds still exsist the company can only blame lazyness for their abscense. For this reason Kotor I wins.

[Zante]

Yeach, do you know there was actualy supposed to be robot planet? There we were supposed to learn the origin of the assasin robots. I think they should release a patch or something and finish it.

[The Last Ancient]

The first one had a much better classic story, and much better characters. Mission, Carth, Bastila, Zalbaar, all better characters then any in Kotor 2. Plus you didn't have kreia talking to you every few steps for two hours(although she was interesting it was like alright I got the point already). The planets are better and the revan - malak saga is more interesting to me then the fallen jedi storyline. That said I still love both games, but kotor will go down as a classic while the second one wasn't as good, not really in the same league.