See, the problem IMO is that you can do, what you've done (in listing some of the characters attributes and why you've put them where they are or why they're hard to list) with every character. It's, as you said, a matter of opinion. I'm sure you could get a person using a low tier character who is that good with the one character that they woop a top tiers ass. It's just to hard to classify.

Stay Essential
EE