lol yes sorry to give the wrong impression. This guide is leaps and bounds beyond the crappy Bradyguide but I'd say ANY guide to FFXI should be taken with a grain of salt.

The thing to keep in mind in FFXI is there general is no absolutism.

Taru+Tank = no no *buzzer* wrong
BST+PT = no no *buzzer* wrong
RDM+melee = NEVER under any circumstance *buzzer* wrong

Just keep in mind that people have a lot of opinions about the absolute answers to things and they are most often wrong. I'm just upset because of the comment saying that 95% of the BRD playerbase all suck. There's a reason we sing the same damn songs. Perhaps I'll start giving the PLD resistance again poison instead of ballad and the RNGs resistance to silence instead of Minuet/Prelude.... pffft.