Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 52

Thread: Denying fate i dont think so

  1. #1
    Viator's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Wrong Dimension
    Posts
    236

    Default Denying fate i dont think so

    A lot of people believe that the reason ultimecia to achieve time compression was to denying her fate death in Squall`s hand.But i think that is not the truth at all.I think the motivation of Ultimecia is quite clear to become the ruler of everything.In the time we meet Ultimecia before final battle she say blah blah blah... The price for your meddling is
    death beyond death. I shall send you to a dimension beyond your imagining. There, I will REIGN, and you will be my SLAVES for eternity.You see, she mean she want all the creature,all the living and death,all existance to become her slave.SHE IS THE ONE.Alright if Ultimecia realy want to deny her fate why she just don`t` kill Squall at the end of disk 1,please don`t tell me that she want he live to tell her the meaning of SeeD because that ridiculous.But she let Squall live because she doesn`t know anything about her fate.Ultimecia(Edea) at Galbadia Garden say so you`re the legendary SeeD that destined to face me(Edea) is not intended say that you`re the one who will kill me later.The reason Ultimecia say that is quite simple.Ultimecia lives in the future so she already learn many history about sorceresses,sorceress war,etc.And she learn in history sorceress Edea defeated by Squall the leader of SeeD and of course in the future Squall will became the legend.So when she say that she already know that she (Edea)will defeated by Squall at that time.That the reasonn why she say that.I hope you understand what i`m talking about.Fell free to share your thought.

  2. #2
    sly gypsy Recognized Member Levian's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Donut Plains
    Posts
    14,210
    Articles
    1
    Blog Entries
    4
    Contributions
    • Former Cid's Knight
    • Hosted the Ciddies

    Default

    Uh, yes. You're right. I don't think it's ever said that she doesn't want to be the ruler of everything. That's just the way of the baddies.


  3. #3

    Default

    a)
    The price for your meddling is
    death beyond death.
    i.e. they will be alive after death but will lose something alive on them (Ultimecia will address it).
    b)
    I shall send you to a dimension beyond your imagining.
    To Esthar.
    Note that our characters went to Esthar but do not fully acknowledge everything that there is on the city.This is proved by looking at the city from the world map.
    From the city there is a road which you can´t pass through.
    And a green lift unaccessed by our characters.
    c)
    There, I will REIGN,
    The expression "I" don´t necessarily refer to Ulti.
    If someone is possessing Ulti the expression I could refer to that person.

    d)
    and you will be my SLAVES for eternity.
    The word "Slaves" can be misunderstood to refer to the slaveness of the entire human race.Slaveness in the sense of threatening people to force them to do things in a workable fashion.
    But it really just refers to our characters.
    In the context of a) the interpretation of the word "slave" is obvious.em
    Ultimecia will kill them and relive them.
    Killing them "kills" their brain content because the brain stop working and the electronical information is lost.Therefore their memories.
    Ulti will relive them again with it´s brain erased.Therefore it will be easier to possess our charascters.Without memories not much will they will have.They will be like babies.
    This way there is no will to resist Ulti´s will.
    Therefore she relived them but "kill" their wills.
    Flo:Honey,the clock is late.Go out fix it.
    Mayor Dobe:What hours is it?
    Flo: 15:30
    Mayor Dobe:Hey do you wanna to send the Estharians to Centra or what?
    Flo:Ok,let it be on 3:45

    Images removed for being utterly colossal. Please use images that conform to the size limit.

    Regards,
    Big D

  4. #4

    Default

    If Ultimecia knew that Edea would be defeated by Squall, why would she then also not know that she herself was supposed to be defeated by Squall? After all, Ultimecia's defeat is far more important historically speaking then Edea's defeat, hence if Edea's defeat is recorded and known, it stands to reason that Ultimecia's defeat would be recorded too, and that Ultimecia would thus know of her own history too. Obviously, it is then quite plausible that she'd want to do something about this (nobody would feel to comfortable at reading that your death is sealed by fate).

    Now, for the line "You are the legendary SeeD destined to face me", you suggest that Ultimecia is speaking of Edea, yet why on earth would Ultimecia refer to Edea as "I"? It is obvious through her speech at Galbadia (which could not have been referring to Edea) that when possessing Edea, any reference to 'I' or 'me' etc. is referring to Ultimecia, NOT Edea. It just doesn't make sense for Ultimecia to use "me" when she's talking about Edea. It is far more reasonable that she is in fact speaking of herself (ie. Ultimecia), ie. her own fate.

    The reasons she doesnt kill Squall in the Desert Prison bit can be many. First and foremost though, there is no indication that Ultimecia even knows who Squall is. When you meet her in the end of disc 1, she only refers to the party as "SeeD", making no indication that she recognises them as being any special SeeD's. It is not until you face her in disc 2 that Ultimecia gives any recognition to Squall (much to his confusement), so in reality, there is no reason to assume she knew who Squall was when she had him captured in the Desert Prison. Further though, you could explain it even if you assume she DID know, by referring to Ultimecia's obvious arrogance ("I'm not only strong enough to defy fate, I'll even keep the man fated to kill me alive just to show how strong I am!").

    Obviously Ultimecia craved power too (ie. compressing and absorbing time and space, making everyone her 'slaves', becoming God etc.), but her recognition of Squall as someone destined to face her indicates an awareness of her own 'fate'. Considering that the peoples awareness of Ultimecia's life through recorded history can perfectly explain why Ultimecia would go all evil in the first place, everything points towards her goal being to stop her fate and becoming God in the process.

    To make this even more plausible, let me refer to the Ultimania Guide (From Selphies Diary):

    "Latest Diary Entry (Public)

    Finally, we arrived at Ultimecia’s castle. Inside, there were a lot of traps
    waiting for us! Our futures were hinged in the balance -- could we do this?

    ...you know, I just thought of something right now. What was Ultimecia
    thinking? She was trying to survive in the only way she knew how, I think. Was she trying to reach all the way out to the past to compress time, so that she could try to erase the fate she knew was in store for her...? Thinking about it that way, maybe what I’m writing is one-sided.

    Okay, moving on! If any of you want to ask me in person, I’ll always be around! Think of it as a treat from your local, friendly Garden Festival Committee Director!


    It goes on, but the important bit is bolded. Anyway, if Square made the effort of hinting at the same thing in the Ultimania, it seems to me pretty likely that this is in fact that Square intended to be the case.

  5. #5

    Default

    No.Square intended for Selphie to think the reality reduces to this stupid time-loop superficial story.Our characters kill Ulti to prevent her from compressing time which she did to prevent being killed.Duuuuuuuh!
    I can understand why Selphie thinks this though.
    Because Dr Odine is a GENIUS!
    Flo:Honey,the clock is late.Go out fix it.
    Mayor Dobe:What hours is it?
    Flo: 15:30
    Mayor Dobe:Hey do you wanna to send the Estharians to Centra or what?
    Flo:Ok,let it be on 3:45

    Images removed for being utterly colossal. Please use images that conform to the size limit.

    Regards,
    Big D

  6. #6
    Viator's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Wrong Dimension
    Posts
    236

    Default

    I believe Ultimecia knew about Squall like i said he will become a legend in the future so everybody in the future know about Squall including Ultimecia.I think someone in here ever say this i think its Qurange she said only few people in Squall time know about Ultimecia and believe.I believe Ultimecia history never recorded in Squall`s time because its just will make chaos in the future.So Ultimecia never know about her fate.Sir Bahamut please just spend sometime thinking that Ultimecia doesnt know her fate and you will eventually realised it.

    PS:OMG i cant believe Lychon is MALE i always thought that Lychon is FEMALE.Come on if you see her/his writing you will assume that Lychon is FEMALE maybe he is lying(i could be wrong...).
    Someday I will conquer all and I will be free -- Believe

  7. #7
    Card Queen Qurange's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Georgia, U.S.
    Posts
    476

    Default

    Hmmmm, I did forget about the Ultimania entry--though I still think it's most logical that /most/ of the world didn't know about Ultimecia, it is more and more likely that Ultimecia, even if she didn't know exactly what was supposed to happen, was trying to change the way she'd known or read things had to be. Now, whether it was common knowledge or whether she simply found out at some point...

    Well, that's all speculation.
    -Q

  8. #8
    Viator's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Wrong Dimension
    Posts
    236

    Default

    What do tou mean she simple found out at same point do you mean her fate?
    Someday I will conquer all and I will be free -- Believe

  9. #9
    Card Queen Qurange's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Georgia, U.S.
    Posts
    476

    Default

    Um, please repeat?
    -Q

  10. #10
    Viator's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Wrong Dimension
    Posts
    236

    Default

    I mean at post number 9

    Of course Ultimecia knew that Edea will defeated by Squall because she is from future.Ultimecia doesnt know that she will defeated by Squall because the event of her defeat not happen yet. (to Sir Bahamut)
    Someday I will conquer all and I will be free -- Believe

  11. #11

    Default

    I am looking at these discussions and though most of them make sense I expect some physical evidence to establish to stablish the true ones (or at least the most accurate).
    Flo:Honey,the clock is late.Go out fix it.
    Mayor Dobe:What hours is it?
    Flo: 15:30
    Mayor Dobe:Hey do you wanna to send the Estharians to Centra or what?
    Flo:Ok,let it be on 3:45

    Images removed for being utterly colossal. Please use images that conform to the size limit.

    Regards,
    Big D

  12. #12

    Default

    I believe Ultimecia knew about Squall like i said he will become a legend in the future so everybody in the future know about Squall including Ultimecia.I think someone in here ever say this i think its Qurange she said only few people in Squall time know about Ultimecia and believe.I believe Ultimecia history never recorded in Squall`s time because its just will make chaos in the future.So Ultimecia never know about her fate.
    Thing is, Squall becomes legendary because he kills Ultimecia. Claiming that Ultimecia knows about Squall being legendary but NOT that he is legendary for beating her, even when Ultimecia literally says "you arethe one destined to defeat me" is simply not rational. Ultimecias acknowledgement of Squall when inside Edea can only mean one thing; she knew that he was the one who was supposed to defeat her (according to history). Combined with the Ultimania quote referred to, as well as the fact that a major theme in the game is that of coming to terms with fate (Ellone's journey to change the past, Squall's unwillingess to be a leader etc.) makes it highly likely that Ultimecia's actions stem from the same thing; a desire to change ones fate.

    One can argue, like Qurange says, about how many people actually knew this, but I see no reason why it shouldn't be well known. The events that shake the world in FF8 are of such a magnitude that explanations will be demanded, and since many people (primarily SeeD's) are aware of the fact that a sorceress named Ultimecia is behind it all, it seems unreasonable to think that the truth could be covered up indefinitely. Further, not revealing the truth would leave Edea as the natural person to blame, which I doubt Squall, or Cid for that matter, would want.

    Now, we know from Ultimecia's speech in Galbadia that she, and other sorceresses of her time were persecuted. Why is that? Well, if people became aware that a sorceress who was yet to be born would kill countless people and nearly destroy the universe as we know it, that'd be a pretty good reason, if you ask me.

    Perhaps the exact details alluded most people, but if Ultimecia was able to find out that her history had been 'sealed', I don't see why we should think she was a rare case. And if people knew about her predicted birth, we have a perfect explanation for why she went all evil.
    It's just too elegant to be incorrect, if you ask me.

    Sir Bahamut please just spend sometime thinking that Ultimecia doesnt know her fate and you will eventually realised it.
    Sorry, but you haven't given any arguments that haven't already been countered, so I see no reason to think that she didn't know her fate. IMO, considering the oft-quote line at the end of disc 2 and the Ultimania quote, I find it absurd to consider that she DIDN'T know her fate.

    Of course Ultimecia knew that Edea will defeated by Squall because she is from future.Ultimecia doesnt know that she will defeated by Squall because the event of her defeat not happen yet. (to Sir Bahamut)
    You're wrong. The defeat of Ultimecia had already happened! You say that she'd obviously know about Edea's defeat, because that was an event in Ultimecia's past, but the fact is that the defeat of herself happened even earlier than that. Observe this timeline diagram:

    ----A---->B----------------->C--->

    A = Ultimecia dies, Edea takes her powers (as seen in the ending).
    B= Edea is defeated by Squall (as seen in disc 2).
    C= Ultimecia rises to power.

    So I'm afraid you're wrong here.

  13. #13
    Viator's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Wrong Dimension
    Posts
    236

    Default

    You`re right I just need somebody to destroy my theory that`s all
    In Deling City Ultimecia only say SORCERESS (HERSELF) NOT SORCERESSES

    But I still believe that future generation doesnt know about Ultimecia.Only few people knew about it in the future, but they keep it as secret.

    I think the reason why she compress time is not to deny her fate.
    She must have another reason.

    "Latest Diary Entry (Public)

    Finally, we arrived at Ultimecia’s castle. Inside, there were a lot of traps
    waiting for us! Our futures were hinged in the balance -- could we do this?

    ...you know, I just thought of something right now. What was Ultimecia
    thinking? She was trying to survive in the only way she knew how, I think. Was she trying to reach all the way out to the past to compress time, so that she could try to erase the fate she knew was in store for her...? Thinking about it that way, maybe what I’m writing is one-sided.

    Okay, moving on! If any of you want to ask me in person, I’ll always be around! Think of it as a treat from your local, friendly Garden Festival Committee Director!

    Doesnt sound like Selphie to me.
    Someday I will conquer all and I will be free -- Believe

  14. #14

    Default

    Riiiight... It IS her, because the FF8 Ultimania SAYS it's her, and it, By the by, is official.

  15. #15
    Viator's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Wrong Dimension
    Posts
    236

    Default

    Believe in what you believe then,period.
    Someday I will conquer all and I will be free -- Believe

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •