Resident Evil and Silent Hill

[ekinserge]

which one destined to be the greatest survival horror af all time?...i will pick Resident Evil...especially when i play Resident Evil 4 for the 5 times...

[I Took the Red Pill]

RE4 was gold. So I go with Resident Evil.

[Cid Vicious]

Resident Evil 2.

[ekinserge]

RE4 was gold. So I go with Resident Evil.

yeah, RE4 is really platinum gold...

[Zell's Fists of Fury]

Silent Hill all the way.
Resident Evil never did anything for me. Silent Hill just rocks.

[~SapphireStar~]

IMO they are both the best. They scare me on different levels. RE has its zombies and giant moths, whilst SH scares me on the "What the f**k is that meant to be!?" level.

[ekinserge]

the enemy especially in RE4 looks great, with el gigante, regenerator, fast zombies and superb bosses really makes it a game of the year...

[Madame Adequate]

For gameplay, Resident Evil 4. For outright scares, Project Zero/Fatal Frame.

[Levian]

They're both awesome, but Silent Hill wins. Resident Evil has the best action set up, though. But Silent Hill has the story, and the scares, and the environments. :o

[Dreddz]

I prefer RE, but only up to the third game, the fourth ruined it for me. Im a RE traditionalist and prefer the old style of the series. Silent Hill has stayed truthful and I love the series, its a very close call to make between the two games, one im unable to fully answer :p

[LunarWeaver]

I like Silent Hill, but I love Resident Evil...They're all so yummy. What is that? Is that Fanboy on me?! Ahh RE Fanboy get it off!!!

[Germ Hamee]

No contest. Nothing has left me as terrified and traumatized as the first Silent Hill. Resident Evil can be intense, but it never ever gets to me.

[GooeyToast]

Silent Hill is definetly scarier, is the better series of the two in general. Although RE4 was one hell of a game, it was more action than horror. I give it to Silent Hill.

[Yuffie514]

...bio-nuclear Nemesis VS the immortalized demon, Pyramid Head? HEH.

Silent Hill is more for the scare factors and focuses on keeping the player constantly terrified. Resident Evil wasn't even scary enough for me to want to quit halfway through. i'm taking a break from Silent Hill after completing Silent Hill 4: The Room. most certainly picking up after Silent Hill 5 debuts.

i did enjoy all the Resident Evil games, including Resident Evil 3: Nemesis for PSX.

[Nick Schovitz]

I haven't played any Silent hill game so Is houldn't put on an opinion, RE4 could've had some horror in it, too predictible when they're enemies around, I suggest that they have a part when you're in toatal darkness anmd the only thinhg you caN HEAR IS A CHAINSAW AROUND YOU, YOU RUN A AROUND IN CIRCLES AND WHEN THE chainsaw weilder attacks, the music goes all daa 1 and scare the [img]/xxx.gif[/img][img]/xxx.gif[/img][img]/xxx.gif[/img][img]/xxx.gif[/img] out of you when the villager barely misses you.