Resident Evil and Silent Hill

[Dreddz]

The gameplay wasnt tedious to me, the fact that you can see through the eyes of the monsters, makes things very tense. Scared the crap out of me sometimes.

[Moon Rabbits]

I think my sig makes me answer apparent.

SH has it all over RE's story, characters, monsters, environments, music, ambience, sound, scares, etc.

[Giga Guess]

Silent Hill...it's everyman survivalist, as opposed to military survival.

[runouni k master]

out of the two im with re4 and re2 sh is two hard

re4 is one of only a few games that i replayed more then one time

another game i played more then one time is dmc 1 and 3 any one else played them

Please don't double or triple post. Use the Edit/Delete button to add to your post instead

[Old Manus]

I found Silent Hill two hard two.

[drunkymonkey]

I prefer Resident Evil. The whole 'let's put disturbing images in our games' part of Silent Hill makes it less scary and more hilarious, in a bad way. Resident Evil 4 was a very, very good game, but neither series is really in my favourites list.

[Shiny]

Resident Evil 4 probably. Although I like Silent Hill more. It doesn't include extremely cheesy lines and bad voice acting like the Resident Evil series does. "Don't. Open. That door!" -_-

[Fonzie]

But...but...Resident Evil 4 came with nice ballistics

[runouni k master]

any one know any thing about re5

[Alixsar]

RE4 is clearly the best because (in the PS2 version, which is admittedly inferior except for this one thing I'm about to mention) when you wear the mafia outfit and use the Chicago Typewriter and try to reload four times, Leon throws his hat in the air and does a Michael Jackson Moonwalker Pose™. Not even Pyramid Head can stand up to that, although it is very close. Very close.

Oh, and The Mercenaries is probably some of the most fun I've ever had EVER. Hunk and I have some sort of symbiotic bond.

[Outer Heaven]

Silent Hill all the way! RE4 was good, but it was more of a Action-Adventure game then a horror game.

[Carmilla]

Resident Evil

RE is the game that 'started' the whole survival horror trend. It will go down as a classic trend starting masterpiece along with Mario for platforming, Street Fighter for fighting games, etc.

I just replayed and beat RE1 for the PS1 last week and it stills plays and holds up remarkably. Not to mention the pure gaming brilliance of RE4...

[runouni k master]

i the re games more because you can get some bad gunes and just blow every thing away and the topic should be cloused becase re4 is the best rated video game on the ps2 even beter rated then sh

[~SapphireStar~]

be cloused becase re4 is the best rated video game on the ps2 even beter rated then sh

Eh, no. The thread should stay open. Just cause youve had your say, doesnt means others have. Have you even played a Silent Hill game? IMO they are far scarier then RE4. And no it isnt the best rated video game on the PS2. In the UK, according to Gamespot UK, Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas is the most popular.

[Shaun]

Silent Hill.

Psychological horror > stupid jumpy clichés.