I was thinking about making a thread like this. Good job, saved me the trouble xD <3

Anyway. My list.

Lord of the Rings: The Third Age
I actually got to go to EA (thanks to Cid and EoFF! <3) and play this game in it's early stages, as well as give feedback. I was just amazed by the game at that stage. It was such a wonderful idea and everything they had so far was gold. So innovative! When EA sent me my advanced copy I was overjoyed and started playing immediatly and I was hooked... but the game soon got bad. My first disappointment came after Moria. I remember all through Moria being super excited that I'd soon get to Lothlorien... and then I left Moria and was transported all the way to Rohan. No in between. I was crushed. Then it got worse. There proved to be very limited NPC dialogue, and no time to just 'explore'. Always stuck in battle scenarios, never just usual RPG in-town time. When I couldnt enter any of the houses in Rohan, I was beginning to get pissed. THEN my game froze after a battle. Outright froze and wouldnt fix. I soon learned that the game was full of bugs and I was just horribly disappointed and pissed. Damn you, EA! You make me sad ;_;. Thanks for the free hotel tho <3

Final Fantasy IX
Let me say that I despised VIII. But I managed to play through it and have a fairly enjoyable time, despite the crappy characters. But IX... it just didnt catch me. It wasnt that the game was flawed, I just didnt get into it. I couldnt make myself continue, hard as I tried. It was quite a let down. I felt like the magic of FF was gone for me (thanks, X, for fixing that).

Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories
Yeah hey, crappy battle system? You make my life teh sux.

That's all I can think of offhand. I'm sure there's more to come.