I'm going to go against the most-used choice here and say the Xbox won, for me anyway. The PS2 won in terms of sales, price and quality (free online gaming, free DVD capability... can't say that about the Xbox), and it had a whole host of great only-on-PS2 titles, but for me the graphics were best on the Xbox, and it skipped the whole memory card annoyance, as well as having a pretty good music system (you can rip tracks very easily onto the Xbox... the only problem with it is it's slow speed).