I thought the gameplay itself was a white-knuckle scary in Re4... so I love it for that... Silent Hill is just atmosphere scary. That's not bad either, but fun+scary is better then walkingaround+scary in my book. I do like Silent Hill stories and settings better though. Hopefully they re-ripoff Resident Evil so I can have a Silent Hill where I'm scared and I get to shoot something too. And no more completely abstract puzzles where I can't move forward in the game unless I use a toothpick on a jar of jelly to make a key.