my favourite from the AJFA album would by Dyer's Eve or Blackened because they're pure Thrash metal style songs, The Black Album had a few good songs such as Holier then thou and enter sandman but it's nothing special considering what they're capable of. But that's why Reload sucked so much (IMO). It was the most alternative rock style and far away from what Metallica were capable of compared to face shattering songs that are just plain sexy. St Anger is a much, much better album when done live. (solos, bass.) St Anger seemed like they were trying too hard to get back to their old style and went too far. James's vocal styles on Reload and St Anger weren't suited for their old Style (not songs, just style) if you noticed at Rock in Rio, Download (2004 and 2006) and Rock Am Ring, Hetfield is bringing the best of both, he's getting his aggressive growl back while keeping similar to his vocals from Load, Reload, Garage Inc and St Anger. This is just all a rough interpretation so if someone else wants to say something too add onto it go right ahead.