My Aeris Theory (some spoilers, I suppose)

[Azuka-San]

Well... to say it as it is, I dont like Aeris, so I dont care if she stay dead

[-N-]

Man, if I had a dollar every time some punk spouted out his or her Aeris theory...

[G SpOtZ]

Man, if I had a dollar every time some punk spouted out his or her Aeris theory...

You would have a dollars, but you wouldn't be classifed as a rich person.

[Mirage]

Note that I don't think Tidus in FF10 was revived, because I don't think he died at the end of FFX.

He was never really "alive" in the first place.

Depends on how you define "alive". If you think someone or something is alive if he/she/it conscious, then Tidus was most certainly alive.

different time zones, wasn't that explained somewhere else?

~OOH, Tidus fight! that was a great opportunity to bring him back then and there and stop my moping about FFX-2

You could see Tidus swimming around in a something full of water at the end of FFX. That means he still existed. That means he was not dead. That means he was not revived in X-2.

[G SpOtZ]

Note that I don't think Tidus in FF10 was revived, because I don't think he died at the end of FFX.

He was never really "alive" in the first place.

Depends on how you define "alive". If you think someone or something is alive if he/she/it conscious, then Tidus was most certainly alive.

Alive in the sense of being "revived", or being brought back from the dead? I don't think so. As you can see, you said "revived" and I based off "alive" with what you said. Tidus was not dead, nor was he alive.

[Mirage]

I'm not really sure where you are going with that post...
I think tidus was alive, because he was conscious. Sure, he was a dream of the fayth, but the dream of the fayth very much existed in the physical world.

But even if he was, as you said, neither alive nor dead, that means he did not die at the end of FFX (something that isn't alive can't die), and he was not revived in FFX-2 (you can't revive something that isn't dead).

[Ryth]

You're funny. ^^

[BardTard]

Someone has too much time on their hands. That's brilliant though. I never would have come up with something like that.

[Dr. Acula]

I have a theory--Cait Sith may not be human. Discuss.

No, it isn't true, I refuse to believe it!

[Pure Aerisbeauty7]

I understand that Aeris was killed by Sephiroth, but then why is there another person like her? It could be her, but I don't see why they changed her name.

[TRANS_AM409]

well in kh hollow bastion aka Radiant Garden is the ff world that the ff games take place and this is befor aris dies cause sephiroth is still alive to this might expain sumthing. man that is an unlucky world there nearly destroyed like 4 or 5 times a year

[Ryushikaze]

^ In a word, NO. KH and FF are not related by continuity.

[TRANS_AM409]

they are theroyes

[Xurts]

I understand that Aeris was killed by Sephiroth, but then why is there another person like her? It could be her, but I don't see why they changed her name.

Actually, Jenova killed Aeris.

[Zeromus_X]

Aerith and Aeris are the same name. And what is so hard to understand about KH and FF being of different continuities?

And yes, a Sephiroth killed Aerith. Shishkebobbed her.