I wouldn't eat it. I would pick it and send it to a museum and get payed for discovering it.
Yes, I would eat it.
No, I wouldn't eat it.
I would feel horrible afterwards... but my wish would be worth it.
I would try to be friend with it and protect it from all the bad guys out there.
I wouldn't eat it. I would pick it and send it to a museum and get payed for discovering it.
I would pick the little wondrous creature up and set him in my room; however, if ever the mushroom became an annoyance, or made threats and so on, then I would immediately go about consuming it.
Or I would go into biogenetics and the like and try to dicover a method of cloning this magical creature. That way I would have nigh infinite wishes...
But if I couldn't discover a way to clone it, and it became an annoyance of any sort, then I would immediately create a lovely mushroom pasta out of it. Nothing has magic go down better than Fetticini Mushroom Chicken/Shrimp Pasta.
...
Aren't all mushrooms living?
smurf that little mushroom, I'd eat it. But not without first gaining its trust and making it think that I wouldn't eat it.
Then I'd make my wish.