Dragon Quest VIII- It was a charming and good game, but it's not really as great as people make it out to be. I'm a HUGE fan of RPGs and I couldn't play DQVIII for long because it was a big bore most of the time.

Vagrant Story- It was an EXTREMELY boring game despite people's claim of it being a great game.

Shadow of the Colossus- I can see how SotC could be a good game, but after you figure out how to kill a Colossus, the game becomes way too boring.

Valkyrie Profile- Even though it's among my favorite RPGs, VP does not live up to its hype. As unique as it was, it wasn't very exciting and it was more of a chore to play the game than it was fun.

Xenogears- I actually hate Xenogears. A lot. It wasn't fun, exploration was limited to a minimum, AND the storyline wasn't as great as the hype made it out to be.

FFVI- Possibly THE most overrated game that I know of. When I first played FFVI, I expected it to be really awe inspiring and breathtaking. Three hours into the game, I was bored out of my mind. The only reason I completed it was because it was an RPG and I never leave an RPG incompleted. Normally, you expect a game to build up more towards the end of the game, but in FFVI's case, the game got more and more boring as you progressed through it.

Surprisingly, as overrated as all those games are, all of them have pretty good soundtracks (except VS IMO), so that's a plus.