What game was quite flawed and should've been seen poor or average if it wasn't for some sort of innovation or charm and story, or whatever was there to make you love it.
That game, for me, was Disaster Report, the graphics and animation were terrible, the acting was iffy, and the game was short. I loved it because, while short, it was different from any other games and had different endings, the gameplay was also different from anything I had played, the aspect of a sinking island hit by earthquakes and all was intriguing to me and I had fun despite it's downsides. Definitely the worst game I ever loved.