Tidus

Pros
Can break the Damage Limit
Powerful Overdrives

Cons
*Coughisablondiecough* Had never even held a sword
Is so lovesick for Yuna he wouldn't even be able to concertrate anyway

Squall

Pros
Has been training for twelve years
Can do about 200 000 damage from Renzozuken and Lionheart
Has a gunblade
Can junction
Actually knows how to hold a weapon
*Coughisahottiecough* Isn't that lovesick over Rinoa

Cons
Is a emo kid

Overall Winner
Vivi. Squall.