The Amazing Race is the only game show-y one that I can stand. I think the constant change of locale and incorporation of local customs and traditions for the challenges keeps it constantly fresh and interesting.

Though I love actual "reality" television. True Life is pretty good and I always catch Miami Ink or The Deadliest Catch whenever possible.

Honestly, it's looking like the reality craze is starting to dwindle. Plot-driven shows are making a comeback.