I saw them live last night and I almost cried. I still haven't gotten over the show - I've been in a daze all day. This was the best show I've ever been to - beat the unbeatable Radiohead show I saw live a few years back.
Seeing them live was incredible - their music is so divine it is still hard for me to imagine it's all created by only four down-to-earth guys playing three guitars and a drum set. If ever there was factual support for the position that God rests in all human beings, this band would be it.
You don't have to have saw them live, or even be a reverent fanatic, to contribute to this thread. What's your favorite song/album/etc.? I can't wait for their new album to come out.