Games you keep coming back to

[RiseToFall]

Final Fantasy VII (don't hate)
Metal Gear Solid Series
Shenmue 1&2
Max Payne
Prince of Persia Series
Devil May Cry 3

[LunarWeaver]

I usually replay any game I own a lot. Ones with lots of story to absorb get played in obscene amount. The MGS games, Final Fantasy VII-X and I'm already on XII's second run (yeah I've played the old ones only once, I must be ebil), Chrono Trigger, Chrono Cross (didn't like it as much but I did enjoy it), Xenosaga, Kingdom Hearts I and II, that sort of thing.

Tales games with GRADE get my vote for best replayability,especially Tales of Symphonia and Tales of the Abyss . Their GRADE shops hold a lot of replay potential, and you even have to play a few times to work up the GRADE to buy everything you want. Then you can put it on a harder difficultly and gogo.

[Lionx]

Klonoa : Empire of Dreams
Capcom vs SNK 2
Guilty Gear XX Reload

[Shaun]

Halo 1, Final Fantasy VII & VIII, the Sonic series, Doom. There are many others I'd like to play more but it's just having time to fit it all in.

[Paro]

Mario Kart 64 is a personal favorite. Me and my friends have a great time with that one. I also love SNK vs Capcom, I can't stop playing it.

[Cruise Control]

Chronotrigger
Golden Sun: The Lost Age
Megaman Battle Network 2
Megaman X (till the Sigma battle, I've never won)
Super Mario RPG
Timesplitters 3: Future Perfect
Valkyrie Profile

[Rocket Edge]

Oh man, uh..

(Not in order)
#1: Final Fantasy VIII (My favourite game)
#2: Final Fantasy X
#3: Syphon Filter 2
#4: Tekken Series
#6: Spyro the Dragon Series (PS1), i developed a love for this series when i was young and i still play it now & again.
#7: Super Mario Brothers 3 (NES)
#8: Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (SEGA)
#9: The Revenge of Shinobi (SEGA)
#10: Golden Axe (SEGA)

I guess the list is long because i don't buy much games.

[Mitch]

World of Warcraft

[Fatal Impurity]

3 games, 2 of which ironically (since i prefer rpg's) are beat 'em ups...

Soul blade (ps1) FULLY completed 3 times
Tekken 3 (ps1) FULLY completed 3 times
Sonic the hedgehog (master system) 8 times

tekken 3 is starting to age for me (because of the lip biting slowness) but sonic and soul balde are still a breath of fresh air for me...strange no?

[Breine]

I always come back to all of the Final Fantasy games... oh, and the Tekken series as well - gotta love that stuff.

[Levian]

Resident Evil 3 - I've finally grown tired of RE1.
Super Mario World - Seen every inch of this game.
Final Fantasy V - Pretty often.
Final Fantasy VI - Now and then.
Final Fantasy VII - Rarely.
Final Fantasy VIII - Now and then.
Final Fantasy IX - Rarely.
Zelda: ALttP - *bows*

I'll probably replay the Silent Hill games when I've forgotten all the puzzles.

[Nasarian Altimeros]

Final Fantasy X. Even though it probably isn't the best, it's by far the most accessible of all the FF games.

[Dreddz]

Guilty Gear XX
Street Fighter 2
Tekken 3
Final Fantasy VII
Rival Schools
Michael Jacksons Moonwalker

[Pete for President]

- Tenchu 2: Birth of the Stealth Assassins. Everytime, this game totally rocks my socks.

- Metal Gear Solid series
- Grand Theft Auto series
- SSX series
- Final Fantasy X. Yes, FFX.

[kikimm]

Baldurs Gate--for PS2. Just cause it's so eay to pick up and start playing, if I'm in the mood to play 2-player.
And yeah Silent Hill. I've probably forgotten the puzzles to 2 by now. Goody!
Does Morrowind count? Yeah it must. I'm always playing that, though.