The Light Saber vs The One Ring

[Araciel]

the thing that doesn't steal your soul plzkthxbai

Hmm. Do you think that the lightsaber would be able to melt the one ring? I forget if mt. doom was special besides being a volcano, so I dunno :O

omg a chance to have a super-geek moment!!

i'm pretty sure the saber couldn't hurt the one ring, since it's a lazer sword...mount doom is the "only place the ring can be destroyed", the ring is a relic created by a god-like being, so the escape clause is very specific....

unless maybe the focus crystal of the lightsaber blade was taken from mount doom...hmmm....

ps i picked the saber...it makes a cooler sound than the ring.

[Ryushikaze]

the thing that doesn't steal your soul plzkthxbai

Hmm. Do you think that the lightsaber would be able to melt the one ring? I forget if mt. doom was special besides being a volcano, so I dunno :O

omg a chance to have a super-geek moment!!

i'm pretty sure the saber couldn't hurt the one ring, since it's a lazer sword...mount doom is the "only place the ring can be destroyed", the ring is a relic created by a god-like being, so the escape clause is very specific....

unless maybe the focus crystal of the lightsaber blade was taken from mount doom...hmmm....

ps i picked the saber...it makes a cooler sound than the ring.

Actually, it's "the fires of mount doom are the only thing hot enough to destroy the one ring", and If lightsabers can't do it, some other beam weapon from SW can.

[Ender]

Actually, it's "the fires of mount doom are the only thing hot enough to destroy the one ring", and If lightsabers can't do it, some other beam weapon from SW can.

lol.

Aboard the Millennium Falcon:
Luke: What's going on?
Han: Our position is correct, but no Middle Earth.
Luke: What do you mean? Where is it?
Han: That's what I'm trying to tell you, kid, it ain't there. It's been totally blown away.
Luke: What? How?!
Obi-Wan: Destroyed, by the Empire.
Han: The entire star fleet couldn't destroy the whole planet. It'd take a thousand ships with more firepower than I've...
Luke: What's that?!
Han: It's a ring. It must have survived the explosion.
Obi-Wan: No, it's THE Ring.
Han: Well it won't be around long enough to bother us.
Obi-Wan: It's no use. You might as well let it go, it can't be destroyed except by being cast into the fire's of Mount Doom.
Luke: Mount Doom?!
Han: I've flown from one end of the galaxy to the other but I've never heard of Mount Doom. And there's certainly no ring that's going to control my destiny.
Obi-Wan gives sly, ironic, smile.

[Sefie1999AD]

Ender: Haha. I wonder how they're going to toss the Ring to the fires of Mt. Doom with the whole planet destroyed, and most likely Mt. Doom too. In that case, a lightsaber or some other weapon had better be able to cut through the Ring.

[Bahamut2000X]

Can this even be debated? A lightsaber is freaking awesome and a sword made of laser! The onr ring....makes you invisible and attracts ring wraiths to you.....I think it's clear here that a sword made of laser qill beat an invisible, undead attracting ring any day.

[Ryushikaze]

Actually, it's "the fires of mount doom are the only thing hot enough to destroy the one ring", and If lightsabers can't do it, some other beam weapon from SW can.

lol.

Aboard the Millennium Falcon:
Luke: What's going on?
Han: Our position is correct, but no Middle Earth.
Luke: What do you mean? Where is it?
Han: That's what I'm trying to tell you, kid, it ain't there. It's been totally blown away.
Luke: What? How?!
Obi-Wan: Destroyed, by the Empire.
Han: The entire star fleet couldn't destroy the whole planet. It'd take a thousand ships with more firepower than I've...
Luke: What's that?!
Han: It's a ring. It must have survived the explosion.
Obi-Wan: No, it's THE Ring.
Han: Well it won't be around long enough to bother us.
Obi-Wan: It's no use. You might as well let it go, it can't be destroyed except by being cast into the fire's of Mount Doom.
Luke: Mount Doom?!
Han: I've flown from one end of the galaxy to the other but I've never heard of Mount Doom. And there's certainly no ring that's going to control my destiny.
Obi-Wan gives sly, ironic, smile.

1e38Mj (or thereabouts) is certainly hotter than Mt. Doom.
It wouldn't even take the Superlaser to do it. a BDZ operation alone not only makes the ring, but the entire planet, a non issue. Superlaser was built to take care of sheilded planets, that could shrug off an 'ordinary' BDZ.

Ender: Haha. I wonder how they're going to toss the Ring to the fires of Mt. Doom with the whole planet destroyed, and most likely Mt. Doom too. In that case, a lightsaber or some other weapon had better be able to cut through the Ring.

Han:Say, Obi, how's tossing it into a sun grab you?
Obi (after some thought):Yeah, that'll do.