Yea i know what you mean about it being a game then on the counter why couldnt a mage be just as good of a fighter as a warrior or what not.

But just one more counter to that heh for conversation piece, its like there are certain aspects that still retain realism like Vaan cant just up and fly or cant walk through walls or cant pick mountains and wail them at someone, but even though its a game...why shouldnt he be able too...is what thinking in game means anything is possible.

Like for example, lets take weapon distribution. If there was a sword you were trying to get called Sword of Greatness, and you took your party in to finally get this sword and actually retrieve it. Would the specialness of this sword be there if when you got the sword it would automatically go into every party members inventory and everyone had it and could use it just as good? Or would it be more special if your main warrior has this sword and is a beast with it?

To me thats how i view classes and skills...just is a better sense of accomplishment when one class excels over another and how its used.

To each his own though, but i just would think most people would enjoy more of a set class.