If Tifa and Aerith fought...

[Firo Volondé]

...over Cloud? This is not a spam thread, it's a serious question. Would Tifa's martial arts skills beat Aerith's magic powers? Who would win?

[Zeromus_X]

Let's be serious, Tifa would pound Aerith into the ground.

[Crop]

Oh come on, Aeris would blow Tifa away before she even got close!

[Jimmy Dark Aeons Slayer]

Overall Tifa is a much better character than Aeris.

Aeris is only a bit better in terms of magic but in all the other aspects she is weakling.

Tifa would smash Aeris with ease.

[Polaris]

Tifa would win! She's punch Aeris like that *makes moves of martial arts* and that *kick the computer* and Aeris would be send to heaven again...

[Darkja]

lol... see the way tifa beat the crap outta loz in advent children? she was flying off the friggin walls and hurling someone probably twice her weight around. no competition, even with aeris' magic.

/

[cloud21zidane16]

aeris stands no chance, tifa would have won before the fight has even began

[MJN SEIFER]

Well Since Aeris can give and take more dangage, can heal her self with out Materia, can seal Tifa's materia to force her to only attack physically and has an actual weapon. I say Tifa's as good as finished.

Aeris > Tifa

[Crop]

Well Since Aeris can give and take more dangage, can heal her self with out Materia, can seal Tifa's materia to force her to only attack physically and has an actual weapon. I say Tifa's as good as finished.

Aeris > Tifa

And I thaught I was backing Aeris on my own.

[f f freak]

Well Since Aeris can give and take more dangage, can heal her self with out Materia, can seal Tifa's materia to force her to only attack physically and has an actual weapon. I say Tifa's as good as finished.

Aeris > Tifa

And considering that Tifa is faster than Aeris, stronger than Aeris, has an incredibly powerful limit break combo and also that Aeris sucks physically, can no way give or take more damage than Tifa and that Tifa can actually fight.

Tifa > Aeris.

[LunarWeaver]

Tifa would only think she's won, but Aeris would summon her lifestream of doom from beyond the grave and Tifa would be smurfed.

I say it's a draw.

[Muse]

Tifa would most likely kick Aeris' ass, unless Aeris kept using her healing abilities.

[Timerk]

I think people underestimate how powerful Aeris was, I mean, she was the one in the party Sephi was worried about, not Cloud.

If she had to, she could beat Tifa in a fight, but Aeris would never fight over Cloud. She would just laugh and walk away, because she knew how things were going to end up anyway.

[Firo Volondé]

And considering that Tifa is faster than Aeris, stronger than Aeris, has an incredibly powerful limit break combo

If we're putting Limit Breaks into the equation, Great Gospel > Final Heaven. Personally, though, I think that Aerith would choose Zack over Cloud, and let Tifa have Cloud all to herself.

[boys from the dwarf]

Overall Tifa is a much better character than Aeris.

Aeris is only a bit better in terms of magic but in all the other aspects she is weakling.

Tifa would smash Aeris with ease.

aeris may have magic but thats only because of materia.

in a no materia battle. tifa definetly.

if they have materia, seems as how aeris isn't massively better at magic, i'd still say tifa.