This thread tickles my fancy

Thank you for making it.
It is, to be honest, a very difficult question to answer. The two have strong similarities, yet critical differences. I feel I am compelled to respond with 'Squid', however, as they have two tentacles more, have a better shape (Which is, incidentally, why Rye prefers squid, although she'll go for anything with tentacles.), and are possibly slightly more intelligent.
Almost all cephalopods, however, are deserving of our utmost respect and reverence. They are beautiful, masterful creatures, and are the rightful masters of the oceans of Earth. I would go so far as to say we should elect a Cephalopod of some description Overlord of Humankind.