The key phrase in your post was "in the Premiership". That sums Lampard up perfectly. He's good in the Premiership. He's great, even. But here's the kicker: England don't play in the Premiership. At international level he has been diabolical for the past 12 months.
Also, Liverpool have more than 60,000 "real" fans, considering that more than one million people turned out for the Champions League victory parade. But plastic fans are an inevitability in football these days, but they pay just as much as real fans do, and apparently moving to Stanley Park is a money-making exercise.