The game gives the player no reason to question the validity of Irvine’s nervousness at that point in time. There is nothing in the way he delivers his lines that implies that he is lying, nor does Squall question his sincerity either. If they player doesn’t consider his explanation particularly believable, there is no reason for the player to jump to anything beyond “the writers gave him pretty lame motivations”.Originally Posted by MJN SEIFER
Is this the scene in question? (script taken from gamefaq.com)Originally Posted by MJN SEIFER
I don’t see anything there that could be called reminiscing. If this isn’t the scene you’re talking about you’ll have to point it out to me.Meanwhile...
Guard: There he is! Over there!!! Seize the escapee, dead or alive!!!
Zell: Tch! Too many! I'm outta here!
Zell moves on but is struck by someone.
Zell: Ugh...
Warden: You bastard... DIE!!!
Suddenly, Squall came up and killed the Warden with his gunblade.
Squall: Didn't think he'd go down that easy.
Zell: Squall!!! Thanks, man!!!
Squall: W-What!? Let go. I said, let go!
The only scene before the orphanage plot twist that actually involves the orphanage in any shape or form is a scene involving Squall (and only Squall) as a child. Only, there is no way to tell from the scene that it’s set in an orphanage and indeed the only thing one can take away from the scene is that Squall had a (at this point unnamed) sister (‘Sis’, later revealed to be Ellone) who apparently left him.Originally Posted by MJN SEIFER
Once again, from the FFVIII gamescript:Originally Posted by MJN SEIFER
This one is probably the most substantial example that you’ve given. That being said, it doesn’t point to anything beyond Squall possibly having heard the name Edea before. Foreshadowing of the orphanage scene would have required at least a subtle clue as to their being a link between the protagonists. Squall’s musing over Edea’s name doesn’t imply this in the slightest.General Caraway: I'm sure you know about the Galbadian government
reaching an agreement with sorceress Edea.
Squall: (So the sorceress' name is Edea...)
General Caraway: There is going to be a ceremony tonight to commemorate
the event.
Squall: (Edea...)



Reply With Quote