Mafia - Game Over!

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Oh, sorry Lev, I was not paying attention. I kinda skimmed fast after I came home from my friend's place.

List of suspects:

Faris: She has been pretty aloof in her playing, remaining ever so mysterious. As well as that she has said somethings to me that makes me suspicious, especially with the whole PM from DK. I will attest to my innocence via that, since I chose to believe DK was a cop when he said he was. Now I am not too sure to believe whether or not all those he listed as innocent to be innocent. He said Resha was innocent and she turned out to be so, but who else would be?

Lekana: In the assumption that she is taking over Psy's role. Psy found out too much so he was killed off. There's two ways that could have happened: he was Mafia and found out who the doctor or cop was or he was a citizen and found out who the mafia was. This is basically a coin toss guess, but I'd say Lekana is Mafia because in his PM DK said Psy was innocent, but did not elaborate.

My next suspect was going to be foa, but I decided against it. At first, something in my gut told me she was Mafia but now, because of DK's PM I think she might be innocent. He had said that after she had convince him that Del Murder was a Mafia, he had "investigated" her and found out she was innocent. Since we know that DK was lying, I would be inclined to go: OMFG SHE IS MAFIA AND THEY WERE WORKING TOGETHER! Maybe DK knew he would be caught and think someone would react like that and intentionally go after foa, thinking he was playing tricks on us. Then again I could be over thinking it.

My last suspect would have to be...*thinks* Shauna. In the thread she declared "not knowing what was going on" yet she had also received the PM from DK. This makes me think she actually knew what was going on and knew that DK was a Mafia member, so decided to vote for him not to look suspicious.

My vote: Faris.

Here's the PM, maybe you guys can get something out of this:

Private Message: Dear Friends
Recipients: Faris, Shauna, The Summoner of Leviathan
TheAbomination
Paulo Wanchope is King
Location: Costa Rica

Default Dear Friends
Hey dudes, this is DK, I can't send any PM's from my normal account so I have to use the old EoY account.

As you might already have guessed, this PM pertains to the mafia thread, where it looks like I'm going to get lynched today! Oh well, we all gotta go some time.

Anyway, here's the reason for me PMing you: I'm a cop. I've got no point hiding it anymore because It looks like I'm a ded man anyway. So yeah. Before I go, I may as well share my findings with you. (I've been a shiet cop anyway :{)

First day, I investigated Paul, who was indeed innocent. Second off, I investigated Resha because...she's Resha! So innocent it must be suspicious! But no, she was innocent too. And after that, fire_of_avalon last night, as she was the one who convinced me that Murd was a mafia. I thought she'd been lying when he turned out to be a citizen, but she's Innocent as well.

So yeah, I haven't found any mafia yet, and I probably won't now, but I thought I'd share these findings with you all in case they might come in handy. I'm off to die now because Radje and Maxx Power seem to have teamed up to get me to die! Shame I won't get the chance to investigate them. :}

[Radje]

I think it's best to discount the PM for who is innocent or not. DK could've put down any names, all innocent, all mafia or mixed. It turns out one was innocent and maybe more if the cop has investigated any of them but that doesn't mean we should pay attention to the PM. It is just a tactic to sway us as we have to realise that we can't ever find out if they are all innocent unless the real cop tells us. Even if he did we can't know if one of them isn't the Godfather.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

True, but I am assuming that DK was perhaps playing a clever game and that the names had intent, or at least some of them did.

I want to put out my last theory as well, that DK and Maxx and/or Redje were Mafia working together. I dunno if this was mentioned by anyone else or not, but it is possible. In the likelihood that the Mafia was losing there power over the citizens, they could have chose one of their own to be under suspicion. Basically, it goes that if DK was right and Maxx was Mafia, then everyone would give up on Maxx and start listening to what he said. The converse is true about DK. Meaning, what if this was all another Mafia ploy to regain control over us citizens? What if we are still being manipulated by them? I like to think Radje is an innocent that got wrapped up into this, but then again he could just be playing his part really well.

[Radje]

I'm worried about Maxx being mafia myself, it would be a horrible trick but very well played by the mafia. I suggest to whoever the real cop is that he investigates him tonight. We need to be sure.

Keep your eye on me too if you still have doubts. I'm willing to disprove them. I'm incredibly surprised I wasn't killed last night myself .

I'm under the impression that the mafia and the citizens are at equal numbers now. That means we can't afford any mistakes. The mafia will DEFINATELY kill a citizen every night, which means we need to DEFINATELY kill a mafia every day. If not we have lost. Decisions have to be made much more carefully and with a lot more discussion between yourselves. If the cop hasn't contacted anyone I suggest he does so. Also, if any other citizen has formed a group behind the scenes please try your hardest to include new members who are the least suspicious. We need one path of voting or else we've lost.

[Captain Maxx Power]

I can see why some people might decide that I might be Mafia based on what happened, but come on people, given the fact that up to that point we'd Lynched nothing but citizens that the Mafia would go to such massive, huge, conspiratous lengths just to win? If that were the case why is it that DK managed to get lynched in the end? If those who had voted for DK in the end were actually Mafia members who decided he should take the fall rather than me, well, why bother with such an elaborate plot? That's what I'm saying guys, we're starting to triple guess ourselves to the point where even those who see to be on the citizen side are becoming prime suspects. I'm not wanting to see myself saved in particular, but I'll be damned if I'm going to see another citizen lynched (namely myself).

[Flying Mullet]

Wow, I missed a lot of drama for two days. Now I have a bunch of make-up homework (reading) to do...

[Radje]

I don't especially believe you are mafia, Maxx. As I said above. However there is a need to make perfectly sure. As I said I want the cop to investigate you, I don't want you lynched.

I suppose we need to wait until people get back from school and work and what not.

[Loony BoB]

The funny thing is that the mafia don't really need to start up anything, it seems the citizens are happy enough doing it on their own.

[Radje]

The funny thing is that the mafia don't really need to start up anything, it seems the citizens are happy enough doing it on their own.

Like you'd be any different if you were a citizen wise-ass :mog:

[fire_of_avalon]

I can see why some people might decide that I might be Mafia based on what happened, but come on people, given the fact that up to that point we'd Lynched nothing but citizens that the Mafia would go to such massive, huge, conspiratous lengths just to win? If that were the case why is it that DK managed to get lynched in the end? If those who had voted for DK in the end were actually Mafia members who decided he should take the fall rather than me, well, why bother with such an elaborate plot? That's what I'm saying guys, we're starting to triple guess ourselves to the point where even those who see to be on the citizen side are becoming prime suspects. I'm not wanting to see myself saved in particular, but I'll be damned if I'm going to see another citizen lynched (namely myself).

But there's always the option that the mafia, whoever they may be, are going to such great lengths for this conspiracy to confuse and manipulate all of us. I still think it all goes back to us not having evidence against anyone. Several members have already listed Old Manus as their prime suspect with very little to go on, other than he changed his vote from Radje to Maxx and that he "argued with Resha". I'm going to go over all of Resha Roo's and Manus's posts in just a while to see if there's really anything worth killing him over.

I also think that Dan's PM was sent mostly to mafia insiders as opposed to innocents. I think that at least two of the people who received the PM are actually in on it, and that Dan picked up one or two patsys (myself included) to fight for him.

Also, I believe there are more than one cop. If there are, I think it's time for at least one of you to step forward, to offer a little more believability to the people you accuse.

[DK]

I have created something beautiful

edit: hahaha sorry Megan, I knew you'd listen to me 'cause you love(d) me. I am a terrible man

[Radje]

I've given a little thought to what BoB said and have come up with a plan.

Everyone who is a citizen, and knows it. Stop talking openly in this thread. Don't spread suspicion of people like i've realised i've done far too much.

There is an underground movement between certain players. I'm completely certain it has been tapped into by the mafia by now however. If you are a part of it, as you know you are, we can work out everything through PMing instead of openly causing questions and suspicions and playing into the mafia's hand. Instead, we'll be working together that bit more, and the cop can get in on it too. To help everyone work out who is a viable target.

If you are in, PM me. If you need more reason to trust me, ask me.

[Rengori]

Rengori: You've voted both ways in this game so far. You eventually voted for DK in that last round, but beforehand you had also voted for innocents. It is hard to place your allegiance. I'm suspicious of you and very curious to see where you stand in the voting today.

No, I just suck at this game and don't know who to vote for, so I just go with the majority.

[Resha]

I am a terrible man

quoted. for. truth.

[Shauna]

My last suspect would have to be...*thinks* Shauna. In the thread she declared "not knowing what was going on" yet she had also received the PM from DK. This makes me think she actually knew what was going on and knew that DK was a Mafia member, so decided to vote for him not to look suspicious.

Well, the only reason I was confused, was because I had got a PM from the real cop also - I believe this cop also contacted Maxx. That and the PM from DK... it had me all confused, and I wasn't sure WHAT I was doing. In the end, I went with my suspicions about the fact that DK had contacted 3 random people - at the time I was thinking "Wait... how did he know to contact us? How does he know we're not mafia?" So... yeah.