Dirge of Cerberus vs. Resident Evil 4

[demondude]

It needs to be a public poll so we can ban everyone who voted dirge of cerberus.

[Kenshin IV]

I-Is this a serious topic? It can't be right? If it is I have to second the guy above me.

[chocobo hunter]

Personally I dislike both Resident Evil 4 and Dirge Of Cerberus but I went with RE4

Resident Evil 4 is a actual shooter game and has a good storyline, the only reason I dislike it is the lack of Zombies until the end but other than that its a great game.

Where as Dirge is nothing more than pretty fmv' with a totally random story arc, that does'nt even stay true to the original game. Dirge is a game that only fanboy' would like.

[MKusanagi]

... must I pick? Leon Kennedy is so bitchin'!!! But so is Vince... You cause me intense pain you evil poll maker!

But I side with DOC in the end. But in truth I'd pick both because they were both amazing in their own ways! Seriously! It's like apples to oranges!

[Kenshin IV]

Link to the Past and Super Mario Bros. 3 are like apples and oranges. RE4 and Dirge are like good game and piss.

[MKusanagi]

It needs to be a public poll so we can ban everyone who voted dirge of cerberus.

doc beotch

i'll kick yo ass *kicks him in his ass*

You remind me of one of those punkish people.

Kenshin IV: RE4 is a FPS about a parasitic organism that has turned an entire village into psychotic, deranged killers. RE4 could be and is actually considered a piss game. The plot is completely outside of the Resi foundations. But it has great gameplay and develops the characters more (Leon and Ada). So I still love it. DOC is a continuation of a storyline in the FFVII series that was never fully explored. In essence, DOC is a necessary stage in Vincent's development. Just as AC was for Cloud. As a lover of both Resi and FF games I still conclude that it's apples to oranges. The only similarity is that they are both FPS. That's it.

[Raebus]

Where to start, RE4 is a FPS? You should brush up on your gaming, it isn't an FPS. I think DOC could be and is actually a piss game. OH NOES, A NEW PLOT WHATEVER SHALL WE DO WITHOUT AN OLD PLOT THAT GOT BORING. I disagree completely.

[MKusanagi]

Alright. TPS. Happy? It's all the same genre. Damn, people get so technical.

And damn, people are pissy on this thread. Sounds like someone's having a case of the mondays...

[Kenshin IV]

RE4 could be and is actually considered a piss game.

Yes it could. By people who have no taste.

[MKusanagi]

I agree Kenshin but I also say the same for those who say that bout DOC.

[Raebus]

Well, those who say that about DoC are actually telling the truth. It's a below average game.

[MKusanagi]

I hate debating games. This is the most pointless thread.
For the record!!! I love RESI 4 and DoC!!! They both rock in my book! And I don't care if you disagree!

Daz right, suckaz hehe...

[Rase]

I hate debating games. This is the most pointless thread.

Than why did you come and post in a thread that was comparing two games, and so logically would feature a fair amount of debate as to which is better? If you feel it's pointless (it's not), there's always the option of ignoring the thread.

[MKusanagi]

I hate debating games. But I love to argue for the sake of arguing. That's why I still come by. But that doesn't change the fact that its a pointless thread. I mean, the entire question is based on personal preference. Just because one person says "Resi rocks, DOC sucks" does not make it true. We are all debating in vain. That is why this is a pointless thread. Because it incites debate on something that can't be successfully debated. No solution will come from this. But I love arguing. So there

[Rase]

The way I see it, this thread is more a way of seeing what the general consensuses is (hence the inclusion of a poll). It isn't an attempt to find out the "truth" of which game is better, but which one individual people like more and to allow them to explain why. If someone disagrees, this also allows them to explain why they feel the way they do. Sounds like a fine thing to me.

You say this is pointless "because it incites debate on something that can't be successfully debated". Welcome to the internet, or more specifically an internet forum. Have fun going to each thread comparing things or asking opinions on things and letting the people in it know that their thread/post is pointless.