Mafia IX: Ace Edition Game Over - Mafia Victory - Town of Failure Destroyed

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

maybe you shouldn't have thrown your vote away on Tracy ...where you even said you knew your vote wouldn't matter.

I did that because I didn't have any concrete evidence on anyone and It was that or don't vote at all and I felt like voting

[[M] Dee]

Yea I see you didn't vote for anyone on day 1 ...and Hotti on day 2 ...and Tracy on day 3, according to Judge's tally, and, you jump around votes all the time. Are you afraid of committing?

I'm tired of reading your posts ...what else should we talk about?

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Yea I see you didn't vote for anyone on day 1 ...and Hotti on day 2 ...and Tracy on day 3, according to Judge's tally, and, you jump around votes all the time. Are you afraid of committing?

I'm tired of reading your posts ...what else should we talk about?

DAy 1 No evidence so I didn't vote day two Hotti because he annoyed me yesterday no evidence so i went for someone who I knew would be safe I changed votes once yesterday when Godot convinced me to wait a day. And on day 1 I jumped a lot to see if people were on but being inactive and if they'd jump to try and save their ass which I already explained to Godot

[[M] Adama]

Okay...It's after 2 am. I've been up since 5 am yesterday. Time to hit the sack.

Gnight all

[[M] Mom – Host]

[2]	[M] Lamiroir:	[M] Franziska von Karma	[M] Furio Tigre
[0]	[M] Luke Atmey:	[M] Franziska von Karma

[[M] Mom – Host]

I'm going to bed so that's the last vote count you'll get from me tonight. :P I'll be back tomorrow.

[[M] Colette]

I'm not going to vote for anyone yet, as Ive just replaced someone and haven't read enough yet to get a good vibe of the people.

I will have some opinion by the end of day 4, until then I will lurk.

p.s. look at my awsome pink glasses. ^__^

[[M] Anise]

Im sticking with Luke, for reasons stated yesterday.

Furio doesn't look very fun to me either, based on giving little information, and on day 1 voting for a guy because he voted for him, something WAY to defensive for a town. But thats just me, and I really don't have much evidence on Tigre other then that, so I don't intend to vote for him.

I also encourage you all to vote Luke as well as me, after enough people start talking of course so we can milk more info out of them.

Also, I was being active, just after I got on.

Remember, I didn't even get a PM to play this time until half way through the other day, and didn't get to post until near the end of the day.

And here I am, posting again.

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

God you guys are fast readers or something. I've gone back through the thread from the beginning but only up through Day 1. Going by what we know for sure, here's what's caught my eyes.

[7]	[M] Mia Fey:	[M] Godot	[M] Kristoph Gavin	[M] Lamiroir	[M] Director Hotti	[M] Phoenix Wright
		[M] Damon Gant	[M] Luke Atmey	[M] Will Powers	[M] Pearl Fey
[7]	[M] Director Hotti:	[M] Polly	[M] Mia Fey	[M] Maya Fey	[M] Damon Gant	[M] Furio Tigre	[M] Will Powers
		[M] Apollo Justice	[M] Klavier Gavin	[M] Bikini	[M] Plum Kitaki	[M] Godot	[M] Pearl Fey
[2]	[M] Phoenix Wright:	[M] Wesley Stickler	[M] Miles Edgeworth
[1]	[M] Godot:	[M] Director Hotti	[M] Luke Atmey	[M] Plum Kitaki
[1]	[M] Apollo Justice:	[M] Phoenix Wright
[1]	[M] Franziska von Karma:	[M] Ema Skye
[1]	[M] Ema Skye:	[M] Jean Armstrong
[0]	[M] Kristoph Gavin:	[M] Mia Fey
[0]	[M] Bikini:	[M] Furio Tigre
[0]	[M] Furio Tigre:	[M] Damon Gant
[0]	[M] Jean Armstrong:	[M] Godot
[0]	[M] Wesley Stickler:	[M] Damon Gant
[0]	[M] Damon Gant:	[M] Kristoph Gavin	[M] Furio Tigre

10 minutes left and we're tied! If we go into sudden death, the first person to have more votes will be lynched.

Miles Edgeworth, why did you vote for Phoenix? The only reasoning I see you put is because "you're an evil bad guy".

I had no one better to vote for since no one really screamed scum to me yet. It was also a half joke as my character looks like the villain type and Phoenix was the only good guy in the series I know of.
But as far as Hotti goes, he's either insane and a very bad cop (and no not an insane cop, I mean player insane), a jester, or mafia trying a very bold move on day one.
I'm leaning more towards jester of this moment.

##Unvote: Phoenix Wright
##Vote: Mia Fey
I'll bite Hotti. Let's see what your up to exactly. Bad cop? Or scum plot?

Here we have the final vote count from Day 1 along with the tie-breaker's vote. First, I'll do what I always do and say that it's most likely that at least 1 (more probably 2, even 3) scum player(s) voted for the lynch victim. Taking those we know are innocent out of the list we have Damon Gant, Lamiroir, Luke Atmey, Will Powers, and Phoenix Wright. All likely scum peepz.

Miles comes out as the last voter for Mia Fey, moving his vote from Phoenix Wright to her. Moves his vote off the person he votes for to join the person he voted for against Mia? WTF, mate? I know it was only Day 1 and things happen, just sayin' it's a bitto weirdo to me.

##UnVote: Godot
Vote: Director Hotti
For reasons above.

There was another post earlier than this one where you just lept out and hopped on Godot. Plum... chica, get some opinions or something! People need your thoughts not your gloomy join-behinds.

Hmm... I dont like this very much. We can either lynch Hotti for claiming cop so early or listen to godot and lynch mia. Right now, I think we should lynch mia and if it seems Hotti is telling the truth, we can have a cop, but if he is lying we can lynch him tommorow. This really seems better right now to me so...
##unvote: hotti
##vote: mia fey

This just sounds weird to me. Not to mention chain lynching again. It really looks like you're not truly committing to either one because you don't care about losing either. And you voted for both.

We have about 1hour and 20 minutes left if I am correct.
I really hope we arent making the wrong move here...

Forgive me for possibly making something out of nothing here but I really don't like when little things like this are added to the end of a post. "I really hope we arent making the wrong move here..." It just oozes fake to me.

BADAAADAAA. Plus, you're on the list of possibles I have at the start of the post. You my #1, baby. #1.

The thing I can gather is that if Hotti really is a cop, then he will die sooner than later from being night killed. I see him as dead in any case soon because why would the mafia want to leave him alive if he can investigate them every day? I would rather take the chance on Mia Fey in the off chance he's telling the truth a cop is really important! DX
##Vote: Mia Fey

I can see some scum in there maybe. You're putting two proven innocents in together almost like a chain lynch. I don't know. I think you were thinking how a townie should think, in my opinion. I don't see why everyone's so worked up about you right now. But still, a little fishy just nothing too major.

Why did I have to be asleep when this started ;_;

##Vote: [M] Godot

Same as Plum, get some backbone.

Damon is coming off as dodgey to me.
Rather then retort an attack, he just dodges it.
True, this is barely anything to go on, but you know what? smurf you all. I can't gauge "crap" with all that damn spam, and I do NOT appreciate getting off work to shift through this much crap.
Edit:
##Vote: Damon Gant

Kristoph votes for Damon Gant, one of those on my list at the top of this post. Kristoph dies that night. Probably coincidence but just pointing that out. Little bits can lead to a big case.

Alright well this is what I know from being Mafia far too much

There is always one mafian member who posts as little as possible, sometimes not at all, just hoping to glide their way through (Auron, Hsu, Ditto). So, voting an inactive off usually gives you a chance at finding a mafian.

Now, right now our list is too big, but give it time and we'll probably nail it down to a 2-4 list of inactives. This is why I lean toward one. Our main problem with choosing one, is we run the risk of either discovering nothing (because the person doesn't show up to defend themselves, turns up town, and the night kill gives us nothing.).

Coming back to this quote by Mia Fey because I agreed with it from the start. Now it's more true than it was back then since we're lower in numbers and we actually have things to discuss. Don't let the people that aren't contributing move on without some resistance. From the list I made, I'm looking at you, Phoenix Wright.

There, that was forever in the making and it was only Day 1. I'll come back after I get some sleep and go over everything else then. :mog:

[[M] Colette]

Before I go to sleep I just want to point out that I'm a replacement and cannot be accounted or defend the playstyle of the person who took this account before me.

We can however say that he/she is a newbie, as experienced players do not take up a mafia game and then suddenly leave.

So don't make quick judgements on how he/she played(because I can't explain that), but if you have a general scum vibe coming from me, a little understandable as for a pro-town role he/she played pretty scummely, then vote away.

[[M] Anise]

Well Mr. Gant, you just moved up to #2 on my list.

Why? "Oh, you can't judge me, for I is replacement". The thing is, everything that happened before did happen, and its something that can and should be taken into consideration.

It seems very scummy to try to remove any evidence that can be used against you without a good reason as to why.

[[M] Dee]

I'll just say it, Gant is #1 on my list today, and now he is even more! On day 2 when I said, "think about why the mafia killed Kristoph" I looked at his posts, and, the only thing Kristoph did was vote for Gant. But, I more suspected Hotti that day, so i didn't want to get killed too in case I said something DX

I notice he keeps talking about wanting to be investigated. He said something about night time inspection at least twice. I read it earlier but i don't want to find it now.
Now, no one barely even said anything about him, and he says "sorry the person before me was playing scummy." No one even said that except him, why so paranoid!
One more thing i noticed when i was reading that seems weird, him and some other people I forgot seem to trust Jean so much ...why?

I'm leaving and putting my vote in case I don't get back, but, like I said I have more time now and i should be back XD

##Vote: Gant

[[M] Elize]

Luke is suspicious to me because he has NOTHING to contribute, and his posts have a sort of...celebratory?...tone to them. As if he's happy about how things are going. As if he's behind it.

Yeah I'm really happy that we keep lynching townies while the scum laugh at how much we suck :rolleyes2


Alright, I want to clear my name so if any of you have any questions I'll answer them. I have nothing to hide.

[[M] Adama]

One more thing i noticed when i was reading that seems weird, him and some other people I forgot seem to trust Jean so much ...why?

Because the person behind Jean's character just oozes charisma. (Don't let that go to your head, you-know-who-you-are...I'll deflate it with a pin )He probably has the most experience out of anyone playing, other than Levian...who died anyway and wasn't able to post except once, I believe, because he worked so much. I'm sure there are more experienced ones among us, I just don't know who all is playing.

Anyway, as I said before...trusting one player to tell you how to vote and all that is VERY dangerous. He turns out to be mafia, we're screwed for life, because he has the most influence over everyone, and we let it get that way. That's why we need to stop the blind follower act now, get our heads together, and work as a TEAM. We're letting the mafia win because we cba to come up with real reasons and we don't want to really look into things, either because we're afraid of being next on the list to die, because we just don't want to trudge through all those posts back there to find anything solid..or we have a LOT of scum in our midst who have the lazy act going on while in reality, they're working extra hard in the mafian forum to get us all killed for the victory. There's no way to know for certain. All we have to go by is the word of each other, and well...Like I said, "Guilty until proven innocent," and there are only two ways to be proven innocent: a fate like Godot's where they scream "I'm innocent, please believe me!" and end up with the noose around their neck anyway, or if a sane cop who isn't played by DD investigates the person and finds them to be innocent, then at some point, informs the town of their results for whatever reason.

Seeing that we're pushing each other to support our votes and thoughts makes me happy, because we're finally gaining a fighting chance. We CAN win, if we keep this up. Don't let any small details pass you by, because they can turn into fatal mistakes if we're not careful.

[[M] Adama]

Luke: who rings most suspicious to you as of now and why?