I actually do think Snape was roleblocked. That was why Beakbeak was murdered instead.
![[M] Gaius is offline](images/images_15/statusicon/user-offline.png)
![[M] Gaius's Avatar](/user/avatar/avatar29627_25.gif "[M] Gaius's Avatar"){kind=avatar}
I actually do think Snape was roleblocked. That was why Beakbeak was murdered instead.
![[M] Al - Biker Dad's Avatar](/user/avatar/avatar29623_28.gif "[M] Al - Biker Dad's Avatar"){kind=avatar}
^ Just about to get round to that, Voldy. Mafia knew Beaky was gonna protect me because everyone was like "'Kay, Beaky, protect Snape." So it was pretty obvious.
And Beaky's role includes a roleblock.
![[M] Aaron's Avatar](/user/avatar/avatar29628_28.gif "[M] Aaron's Avatar"){kind=avatar}
I'm torn, honestly.
Snape: Could all be a bluff, but do we take that risk?
Hagrid: Seems to want rid of Snape, is he over obvious scum? Or a very clever townie?
Dobby: Where is he? I feel inclined to vote him him...
![[M] Elize's Avatar](/user/avatar/avatar30306_21.gif "[M] Elize's Avatar"){kind=avatar}
Hi, I'm back guys.
You're right, Hagrid. I've been thinking about this since I mentioned that there are two mafia's. Snape calling out on two unlynchable roles seemed awfully suspisious.
The thing that did it for me is the fact that Peter does not behave like a Jester at all, more like the opposite.
And if we don't know for certain if Snape is the record keeper, he could have a problem. If we rule out 3 players that could be mafia, and start killing off townies instead, we could risk losing all together in a day or two.
I for one, do not want to take that risk.
##vote: Snivellus
Oh and Myrtle, I noticed something.
Explain, please.Originally Posted by M Moaning Myrtle
And Dumbledore, please don't vote without reason.
I shouldn't have edited that out. Might have done it by accident when I was correcting a spelling mistake.
Okay, I've decided that this is the best course of action.
##VOTE: SNAPE
Filch went along with snapes claim, could Filch be mafia to?
I thought Voldy was guilty at the time, I meant we'll deal with Snape after Voldy, but then I figured out that Voldemort was in fact a Mason.
How would I know Dudley was the Godfather then? Also, Lupin, Filch does have a lynchable role. He just can't be targeted at Night.
You could be on Dudleys team, and you decided you'd preach the truth so you looked innocent.
^Why would I want to get rid of my Godfather?
You are a rolecop, you investigated it. And in retaliation for your Godfather, you could've devised this plan to kill off theirs.
If we are wrong about this, I'm sorry, but we can't afford to take the risk anymore.
If you all are mafia, we could be on a losing streak, lynching off townies until we all die.
And Peter's inactivity as Jester just seals the deal. It doesn't fit.
And having no other real suspisions at the moment, I have little choice.
Last edited by [M] Elize; 08-19-2008 at 05:52 PM. Reason: meant rolecop
It'd make you look innocent, and Dudley wasn't doing anything.
Myrtle, it'd be better to have my Godfather then to look innocent. At the moment you seem scummy. You've just jumped on a Bandwagon that you've never believed before. Well, when the rest of the town gets night killed it'll be funny to say I told you I wasn't Mafia.
Lynch me then, you'll die indefinitely when it's revealed I'm just a townie.
Besides why would I clear Voldemort if I was mafia?
It did not go unnoticed, Snape. Neither did her comment to Hagrid.
But Myrtle is DD, and however we shouldn't let that trouble the game, I recognize how he fails tremendously, and usually without being mafia.
That however, doesn't mean I don't keep a very close watch on her, as I've shown in my first post.
Posting Permissions
