Mafia XIII: Game thread! - GAME OVER - Hail to the Town!

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

Lincoln:

I didn't mean early in time, I meant early in the order of people who voted for him. You say Jefferson acted suspicious, I disagree. I think he was acting a bit crazy, but not suspicious. It's as simple as that. Your evidence didn't turn out to point in the right direction now did it? Jefferson was not the fish we were trying to catch.

I do understand what you're saying and I see your reasoning for voting for Jefferson, but I still think the path you decided to take would be an easy path for a mafia to take.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

If you ask me it was fairly obvious Jefferson wasn't mafia. I concur with Kennedy when he says we should be looking at Lincoln and Jackson for the votes.


This is a replacement, btw. I'll probably post a bit more later, no promises.

[[M] Apollo]

I think the bandwagon came from him roleclaiming and such. Acting like an idiot, and before anyone says anything it was in a different way than what Bill did. Bill was annoying, while Jefferson was distracting.

[[M] Apollo]

Hello George. Now, why would you think that something that seems obvious to you would be obvious for everyone?

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

Seriously people I wouldn't mind if you use good, true evidence on me, but if you are going to lie, then Im gonna be an asshole.

God, relax. You have 1 vote, and I haven't lied.

True evidence? What's that supposed to mean? I'm sorry but I don't need any DNA match to vote for you. My feeling that you're a mafia is just a hunch and I'd say it's more probable since you're one of the people who voted for Jefferson.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

That's Mr. President to you, Mr. President. And yeah we get it. Different people have different perspectives on things blah blah blah. If he had turned out to be mafia he would be the most retarded mafia in EoFF history. Even if it turned out like Ace Attorney mafia where everyone in the mafia "tried" to get the Godfather lynched.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

I find this helpful so I'll post it again. Voting history for day 2:

Jefferson - FDR
FDR - Nixon
Reagan - Teddy
FDR - Jefferson
Adams - Teddy
Teddy - Nixon
Bush Sr. - Clinton
Jefferson - Clinton
Lincoln - Jefferson
Obama - Jefferson
Taft - Jefferson
Reagan - Teddy
Taft - Nixon
Reagan - Jackson
Reagan - Teddy
Jacskon - Reagan
Obama - W
Clinton - JFK
W - Teddy
Jefferson - Teddy
Jefferson - Clinton
Jefferson - Roosevelt
Teddy - Jefferson
FDR - Roosevelt

What do I take from this? Teddy had an early vote on Nixon so he's probably not scum. Also Adams had an early vote on Teddy so he probably isn't scum. W voted for Teddy when Jefferson was leading the way so I'd say for now he's safe too, but not as much as the others.

FDR only voted for Teddy when it seemed his goose was cooked. Something about FDR smells wrong. If he didn't make the tiebreaker on day 1 I would have had him in my sights. But maybe that was the intended purpose of that.

[[M] Apollo]

Fine ok everyone Im actually a mafia serial killer. You caught me and I give up...

Would you vote for me?

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Also Teddy jumped on Clinton in Day 1 and encouraged a bandwagon. Could be trying to sacrifice a mafia, but that's pretty ballsy for day 1.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Lincoln seems way to defensive for only having one vote. Also he defended Teddy on day 1 when Eisenhower voted for him:

Eisenhower , what do you mean? He hasn't really said anything yet besides a small opinion about a vote. I don't see how he is trying to show that he is contibuting...

Now take a look at these two posts:

Now I think that Roosevelt is just as bad as Eisenhower.

Eisenhower: This is not a time to be jokevoting. Why would you vote for Bill with no suspicion and no way of convincing yet again

Roosevelt: I think you are just bandwaggoning, and I know sometimes a townie would like to bandwagon but mafias do too. I really don't see why you think Eisenhower is with Reagan. If you could expand on that a little, maybe it would be better for all of us.

Ok thank you Roosevelt for expanding a bit. I don't fully understand what you are getting at, but at least you did explain it.

Eisenhower, I still don't see why you would go for one person just because it seems more likely he would be lynched.

Teddy didn't post in between them. How can he thank him for something that never happened? Could just be trying to look like he suspected Teddy. Finally:

I am also going to be watching Bill Clinton. I hope you will start to post more. I am not really too suspisious of you, but if I can't find a better vote mine will be for you.

Why vote for someone you aren't suspicious of? Seemed unwilling to vote for him not too long ago:

People, look back at old games. The person who is acting dumb(mostly is was Demon Dude) is almost never a mafia member. In fact, I don't remember a time where a mafia was acting idiotic. Bill is just someone taking day 1 a little too unseriously.

Mafia like to come up with reasons to vote people without actually suspecting them.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Huh. Look at that last quote. He had no problem voting for Jefferson o.O

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

Oh, this looks fun.

[[M] Athena]

I'll be honest, Reagan is making pretty good points against you, Lincoln.

Nixon, what do you think? I don't believe you've ever told us who you believe is scum yet.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Huh. Look at that last quote. He had no problem voting for Jefferson o.O

A good point! A lot of us thought Jefferson was just acting dumb and not really a mafia, which turned out to be the case. This is basically what Lincoln was trying to say about Clinton, yet he voted for Jefferson. Inconsistent!

Lincoln wasn't my top suspect going into today. But people were talking about him so I thought I'd weigh in.

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

I have said that I thought Teddy was scum. Taft, I have my doubts. That is besides the point though. As of right now I like you Bush Sr.