Mafia XIV Game Thread - GAME OVER - Cult Win! Skulls for the Skull Throne!

[[M] Mom – Host]

Really hope no one saw me post with me real account there! If you did, don't be a meanie and ruin all the fun! ~50 minutes left.

[[M] Felix]

Why would Chocobo do as we say?
The chance to live another day?
There's no point in playing if he's already lost
I think leaving him alive would have a deadly cost
He could do whatever he wanted, he knows he's already dead
I don't know about you, but I don't want a bullet to the head!

And yes, he could potentially kill the mob
But the lynch is more suited to that job.
If we have someone who we think is bad
Lynch them, and there's vote analysis to be had!

[[M] Colette]

Argh, lost my post. Here it goes again:

Siren, you seemed to vote for Chocobo quickly as he neared a majority vote. To me, it looked horrible, not to mention that the only reason you gave after the fact was that you just didn't know who else to pick. Why Chocobo?

[[M] Mom – Host]

I never post with my real account.
-The other Rydia

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

[QUOTE='[M] Odin;2783844']Indeed activity was promised, so here it is.

So some of the best information we have to go on right now is what happened at the end of the day where we had the 3 way tie. Here's how the tie broke out and who voted for who:

Bahamut (2): Shiva, Leviathan
Ifrit (2): Bahamut, Cactuar
Cactuar (2): Chocobo, Ifrit

The following people posted in 'Sudden Death' (in this order):

Bahamut - I'd like to ask Bahamut why he let the Sudden Death play out rather than save himself by switching his vote to Cactuar.
Carbuncle
Cactuar (why didn't you save yourself by voting for one of the others? )
Chocobo
Shiva
Titan - broke the tie with his post.
Valefor - technically my post didn't get off until after the day ended but I'll count it anyway.

Now, I'd like to think that if a mafia was up for lynch in a three way tie on day one, another mafia would save their butt. And if Bahamut was mafia, why wouldn't he save his ass right away? It's possible there is some deeper strategy here but it is too early to get into that right now. In a few days we'll have more evidence to shed some light on this.

Based on that evidence I have to assume right now that Bahamut isn't mafia. And I never really thought Ifirit was mafia. So that would mean it was a three way tie between three townies. The mafia would know this, and would have no reason to break it.

Too many people didn't vote yesterday. We need more votes! The day is already halfway over and we have like 3 total votes. As for my vote, it stays on Leviathan, because I still don't like his reasoning behind voting Bahamut.

[[M] Mom – Host]

32 minutes before sundown.

[[M] Anise]

If Chocobo is the Serial Killer, then he cannot live. He's already said that if he lives, he will kill. Lynching him is not a waste as he poses a very real threat to every town member. I would much rather have one townie death every night than potentially two - we don't have the numbers to sustain that many losses.

[[M] Gaius]

Odin you should probably fix that post or repost it.

[[M] Apollo]

Argh, lost my post. Here it goes again:

Siren, you seemed to vote for Chocobo quickly as he neared a majority vote. To me, it looked horrible, not to mention that the only reason you gave after the fact was that you just didn't know who else to pick. Why Chocobo?

This's silly. Why not vote for [M] Chocobo? First, Serial Killer, second, everyone's already voted for him. Voting for anyone else can get you questioned and why not string up a known danger?

[[M] Colette]

Didn't you already post that, Odin? I'm confused. Anyway, addressing the question about why the "first" Bahamut let Sudden Death continue... I can't say why because I'm not the same person. I have a feeling that Ifrit is Town aligned, though, so I'm glad the "first" Bahamut played it that way. And we now know that Cactuar was Town aligned, so it would have made me look bad if "I" would have voted for them.

Current Vote Count

Anima - 1
Bahamut - 1
Chocobo - 6
Doomtrain - 2
Ifrit - 1
Ramuh - 1
Valefor - 1

It looks as if Day 2 is coming to a close without anything else happening. I might as well come out with my role now before something strange happens and people get confused.

I am a Death Miller. I'll come up as a baddy if investigated and even if I die, I'll still be revealed as a baddy. What a horrible lot! But hear this: I suggest that no Town aligned roles with night activities target me as it would only lead to confusion and cause unwanted hysteria for the Town. If a Cop targets me, they'll get scum. How does that help the Town? Technically, I could be saved if a Doctor protects me and someone tries to kill me but I'd rather go down during the night if possible to show that a "Mafia Goon" died in the night. I highly doubt that there are two rival Mafias with only so few players and if Chocobo is a Serial Killer and we oust him, then I doubt it would be very possible to kill a baddy at night.

Think this over during the night, please.

[[M] Apollo]

That's a lot to toss out without asking, kind of reaching there, huh? If he does not die tonight, he looks pretty good lynching material tomorrow. I know, cruel words.

[[M] Gaius]

What a convienent claim. We really have no way to verify it even if you die! Can anyone come up with a plan to verify Bahamut's claim? I sure can't.

[[M] Felix]

Bahamut's claim has just caused me some fear.
I'd like a Doc to consider protecting my rear.

Bahamut, your claim is extremely strange!
Tonight, everything is going to change.

[[M] Colette]

I'm not reaching at all, Shiva. I'd rather it be known now than at the end of the game. The game of Mafia isn't about trust. I'm giving you information and you should think for yourself whether I'm lying or not.

There is no way to verify that I'm a Death Miller until the end of the game that I can think of, either! That's why this role is such a royal pain, obviously.

If I die by lynching and the Town thinks that they've killed a Mafia member, then the Town will really kick themselves in the end if we lose. You can't trust me, you just have to use the information I post.

[[M] Caprica]

I can't either, but I can say that Death Miller role is beneficial to the mafia exclusively (unless you count the fact that the mods get a good chuckle out of confusing us as a benefit )