FORWARD MARCH! I've been scouting out the thread and I have two theories.

The Siren Theory

Lt. Siren has been playing it low key for the entire war. Hasn't even voted except once, for Cpl. Valefor - but this is crucial - only after the tie had already been broken so her vote would not count. Rather convienient.

0-Yesterday-Hundred hours, Gunnery Sergeant Ramuh was all over Lt. Siren's . Was totally obsessed and even came up with a trap to try to get her. Yet today he has made absolutely no mention of her and instead goes after Cpl. Valefor. I think that if Lt. Siren is the leader, poor Gunny Ramuh was last night's recruit.

It is as clear as a polished M16 to me that under this scenario, the cult want Cpl. Valefor lynched. Is he one of them? Possible. Titan has obviously been forced to sign up to the cult if Lt. Siren is the leader, and I suppose it would've come around the time of his false insane claim on Pvt. Doomtrain.

Theory 2: The Valefor-Odin Alliance

I strongly suspected Cpl. Valefor yesterday of being the cult leader. I have been trying to figure out who would be his squad mates if this was true. I think the most obvious of these would be Lance Cpl. Odin.

On Day 2, Lance Cpl. Odin and Cpl. Valefor clashed, with Lance Cpl. Odin putting a vote on Cpl. Valefor and the two had a little bit of a bicker. This completely stops on Day 3. Clearly, one of them decided to recruit his foe on Night 2. Instead, Odin goes after the power roles, myself and Colonel Carbuncle, coming out with some FUBAR theory about a Mafia Cop. We all know there is no Mafia, and it would make sense for a Cultist to try to find evidence that there is.

I would also like to draw attention to Odin being low key for Day 1 and 2, and Valefor doing the exact opposite, and then on Day 3, the roles were switched.

Which of the two is the enemy General? I'm not sure, sir! *salutes*

However, judging from the sheer speed at which so much infantry has massed against Valefor, while nobody has even mentioned Odin, it stands to reason that he could well be the lower-ranked grunt taking the hit for his Officer as his fellow soldiers conduct friendly fire (although I don't think everybody who voted for Valefor is cult. Hell, I did it yesterday!), and that would be why I am worried it might be Odin instead.