Mafia XIV Game Thread - GAME OVER - Cult Win! Skulls for the Skull Throne!

[[M] Adama]

Lynching Valefor seems like the best idea. Preferably I would want to lynch someone who stands out more as a Cult Leader. But think about this. What do we really have to lose by lynching Valefor? If he is the Hag our night phase is skipped according to him about his role which is a good thing because then Cult cannot recruit and we'd still have another day to figure out who the leader is. It would be 5-5 then. If he is a Cult member then we've got rid of one and go us. 1 cult out of possibly 5 down and 5 town. It would be 5-4 then. Hmmm

[[M] Adama]

Why would we have two of the same roles? Beloved Princess and Hag have similar actions?

[[M] Apollo]

Either [M] Rydia thought she had a great idea or [M] Diablos thought if we have one, we'd believe him about having the other.

We don't actually know if we have a Hag.

[[M] Adama]

He also posts a ton that day about how everyone is on his case and tries to vote for [M] Carbuncle. I disregarded [M] Carbuncle's suspicions because he suspected me too and maybe it was a lot of random finger-pointing on his part, but [M] Odin didn't like it and when he realizes we're liking [M] Doomtrain for a Cultist, he jumps on that bandwagon. He also says he has stuff to do (understandable) but then says he'll come back but might not post (why come back, maybe to do a night action)? He could've been too late to post, but in hindsight, it's susceptible.

My finger pointing is never random. I pointed fingers at you because saying keep the serial killer alive and investigate me instead of a Ramuh is still an extremely scummy thing to say but makes sense now that the Nexus is explained.

[[M] Adama]

Valefor no where to be found. Ramuh fishy. Odin fishy as usual. Titan confusion. Siren not helping as usual.

[[M] Apollo]

Pretty good summary. And I really thought the Serial Killer idea wasn't bad. It's not as if he was going to kill me.

[[M] Felix]

Alpha squad, secure the perimeter!

Valefor is a good choice, Siren is a good choice, Odin is a good choice. I am still torn. I think Valefor is the most likely of the three to be cult - and I don't think he is a hag - but I also think he is the least likely of the three soldiers to be a General and it's the General we need, unless Carbuncle pulls off a miracle tonight.

[[M] Apollo]

Votecount
Siren(3): Phoenix, Leviathan, Ifrit
Valefor(3): Diablos, Titan, Ramuh, Shiva, Siren
Titan(1): Valefor, Ramuh
Ramuh (1): Ramuh

Not Voting: Carbuncle, Shiva, Odin

Is this how we're looking?

[[M] Elize]

Lynching Valefor seems like the best idea. Preferably I would want to lynch someone who stands out more as a Cult Leader. But think about this. What do we really have to lose by lynching Valefor? If he is the Hag our night phase is skipped according to him about his role which is a good thing because then Cult cannot recruit and we'd still have another day to figure out who the leader is. It would be 5-5 then. If he is a Cult member then we've got rid of one and go us. 1 cult out of possibly 5 down and 5 town. It would be 5-4 then. Hmmm

I agree.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Game opened at 10:48EST, it is now 8:08EST. ~2hrs and 40 minutes remaining.

[[M] Adama]

I think Ramuh wanted to try to get me to vote for him so I wouldn't vote for the Cult Leader or he wanted to get me lynched because I can roleblock the Cult Leader. Either way, Ramuh is not to be trusted.

[[M] Apollo]

[M] Ramuh can be cleaned out later as long as we stop the Leader today or tonight.

[[M] Felix]

Does anybody who has voted for Cpl. Valefor actually thinks he is the leader? I honestly don't care about finding out whether or not Sgt. Titan is to be trusted with a lynch because it is a lynch we can ill afford. We should've shot Cpl. Valefor yesterday tbh, this is a case of shutting the stable door after the horse is bolted.

I'm really worried that many of you are not seeing the bigger picture. ie, we could well lose if we don't get the leader. Frankly, I don't think Cpl. Valefor is a Hag. I think he's Cult through and through. I am just not convinced that he is the leader.

[[M] Elize]

I think Valefor may be the leader. and even if he isn't, it would be better to prolong out death than to aid it.

[[M] Apollo]

I would think [M] Odin was the Cult Leader, but the odds of stringing him up are slim.