Mafia XIV Game Thread - GAME OVER - Cult Win! Skulls for the Skull Throne!

[[M] Caprica]

unvote

##vote: odin

[[M] Anise]

I've read not only your post Ifrit, but also that of Shiva and Carbuncle. It's pretty convincing.

Oh, one bonus note: [M] Odin voted for [M] Valefor on Day 2 immediately. Failed recruitment and then an attempt to neutralize a power role?

This is especially alarming, because like Shiva says here:

The final nail I can draw up for this guy is when he says he suspects the Cult can't recruit power roles. I could have sworn we all had thought [M] Titan was half-compromised since he was a good Cult target. But what if he wasn't because he was a power role? [M] Odin might've tried to recruit him and got burned, or he knew the Leader tried and failed

Everybody seemed at least partially suspicious of Titan because he would be an obvious target for the Cult. Was there a basis for his suspicion? Other than being a Cultist, that is

Also that bolded bit I see Diablos has quoted in my preview is concerning.

If I recall, we still have a bit of time, so I'm just going to mull it over a bit while longer. Now is not the stage to rush things.

[[M] Anise]

Whoa Miss Leviathan, while there is ample evidence, could you point out why you voted? What exactly reeks of Cult to you?

[[M] Adama]

Ifrit, theory 2 is also possible. I find both of your theories to be equally possible. Howeverr, I have a slight bias against Siren due to the fact that she hasn't done hardly a thing to even pretend to help. Laying oh so very low is not helpful in the least and a very good reason for me to believe her to be Cult leader.

I see two problems right now.

1.

Night 2 - I chose Ifrit because I was iffy about his role. I wanted to see what he'd say after he got roleblocked and protected and it confirmed for to me that Ifrit definitely had a killing ability at night. He says he went after Bahamut and Bahamut is still alive so we can presume this. Chocobo coming up as guilty for Ifrit and then it being revealed that Choboco is also a serial killer also tells me that Ifrit is most likely not lying.

The theory of there being no mafia isn't the only way of explaining Ifrit not dieing. After all, the mafia might have tried to kill him.

2. If the cult can recruit, what if Doomtrain isn't the recruiter? Titan, can you be recruited?

You know, we could always just check Titans claim tonight and lynch Doomtrain, and have him check out Shiva tonight. Kill two birds with one stone.

If Titan dies tonight however, regardless of his role, we get Shiva tomorrow.

Well, I agree that Odin and Shiva are suspicious, but I think for today I will be going with Doomtrain.

##Vote: Doomtrain

I don't really know what to say, does anyone have questions for me? (I don't know the capital of Malawi, nor Assyria, in case you arre wondering.)

They are likely to target Titan regardless right now. There isn't much stopping this from happening at this point.

Either

1) The enemy has the Roleblocker, and from here on out will prevent Titan from revealing their Identity.

2) If we have a doc, he's most likely defending Titan if Doom flips scum, or perhaps you 'supposedly' will if you get the power of a doctor tonight.

3) If we have no doc, Titan is dead regardless.

4) If they are something like a cult and can't kill, they'll try recruiting Titan. If they can't recruit power roles, then Titan lives and gives us a reading on Shiva.

Regardless of me saying that, Titan's fate was already decided. ;p

1) What happened day 2 and night 2 both can point to either that or the Mafia Cop theory. Why is it you are so sure it's the one Ifirit claims to be true? Whats tipping the scales in his favor?

2)

I don't think Ifrit is mafia, weird roles are rarely scum.

Hello. I'm sorry if I'm suspicious. And I'm not new, I'm just really really busy lately. D:

Ramuh is pretty suspicious, but my true feelings are for Ifrit. Feelings of suspicion I mean.

...Care to explain the jump in logic between those two quotes?

1) What happened day 2 and night 2 both can point to either that or the Mafia Cop theory. Why is it you are so sure it's the one Ifirit claims to be true? Whats tipping the scales in his favor?

And what be yer evidence that I be a Landlubber Cop, Odin lad? That I be gettin' a serial killer lynched? Arrrr, Cap'n Ifrit be sorry about that, Odin! Next time he be gettin' a guilty result, he be keepin' it all to himself because the only people who be capable o' findin' bad guys clearly be Landlubber Cops.

And what proof do you have of your own claim Ifrit? All you have is you caught the serial killer. And? That supports both cases. It's also entirley possible it was a lucky guess on your own part. Why should we believe your claim Ifrit? You can't prove your target was Bahamut, can you? All we know is last night someone didn't die.

And Carbuncle, what about a townie cop? They have reason to stay out of the limelight, to avoid negative attention and mafia kill to protect a town power role, the same as the doc. Mafia are not always the only ones with reason to hide.

[[M] Adama]

You know, we could always just check Titans claim tonight and lynch Doomtrain, and have him check out Shiva tonight. Kill two birds with one stone.

If Titan dies tonight however, regardless of his role, we get Shiva tomorrow.

^ How do you people let this guy go this long without being lynched?

[[M] Elize]

Yeah, I think I will vote Odin

##Unvote: Valefor
##Vote: Odin

[[M] Elize]

Well, looks like Diablos won't be coming back until 5 years later.

##Vote: Odin

About 2 hours ago I got a 0.0.4 on my 3rd or 4th try, and I thought, "Hey, maybe this won't be as bad as I remember! Maybe I got better since then!"

I hoping the game will pity me, so I'll check out Odin while I'm waiting for my timer to max out.

If anyone cares, it didn't smurfing work

[[M] Anise]

##Unvote: [M] Siren
##Vote: [M] Odin

[[M] Caprica]

erm, lynx?

Also, the quote Carbuncle just bolded (too lazy to quote his quote lol) is actually the one that sticks out most to me. Lynch shiva no matter what titan turns out to be? Really? Does that make sense in ANY logical universe?

[[M] Anise]

Bad luck Diablos, that Sigil can be tough sometimes.

[[M] Adama]

It makes sense for Odin because he is Cult. Lynching a Nexus would be a good thing because he can't recruit a Nexus if this game isn't more bizarre than it already is.

[[M] Felix]

Halt, soldiers!

With 6 votes, and 11 players, does this not make a speed lynch?

General Rydia?

[[M] Adama]

Siren and Valefor since you were once tied, what are your thoughts?

[[M] Apollo]

erm, lynx?

It was only a matter of time, given our track records.

Votecount
Siren(0): Phoenix, Leviathan, Ifrit
Valefor(2): Diablos, Titan, Ramuh, Shiva, Siren
Titan(1): Valefor, Ramuh
Ramuh (1): Ramuh
Odin (6): Ifrit, Shiva, Carbuncle, Leviathan, Diablos, Phoenix

Not Voting: Odin

[[M] Gaius]

Ok, I'll bite. I'm always escaping these by the skin of my teeth!

##Unvote: Titan
##Vote: Odin

Please be cult leader!