Seifer and Squall are brothers

[Serapy]

Not really. Answer this question yourself, if VIII wasn't ambiguous, then why are people still debating about it on various sites, such as here and gamefaqs? Also, if it wasn't ambiguous, then why are there so many explanations on the guides/FAQ page of gamefaqs (e.g. Time Plot) ?

It gives people something to talk about it regardless if it has any point other than killing time. Just because people like debating things doesn't make it ambiguous. It just means they misunderstood what they saw or heard. Not everything is a gray area.

Nope. Let me rephrase, if VIII wasn't ambiguous, then more people would understand VIII more clear, since they always look forward to answers straight away. But they couldn't, because there are important things in VIII that are subtle or lacking more information. E.g. Ultimecia lacks her backstory and she's one of the most important characters in VIII.

And if you have ever played VIII before, you would know that it's more demanding than other FF games in terms of things like this one.

So, all of that doesn't mean us players misunderstand the game...

Scars aren't genetic. If you watched the beginning, you'd know that they scarred each other while training.

That's my point. If two minds know the coords of something very well (e.g. where to attack), then they are likely to be identical somehow. Genes in same families are more identical than different familes. Therefore...

I don't even understand your point here.

A brother usually copys his own brother's actions in some way. Having a dream and all...

Another theory with no reasoning behind it. And they look similar because they're not real. It's a lot harder to design people and have them look different when they're not real.

It's reasonable, actually. When a designer draws multiple characters, and if two of his characters happen to be more identical to each other than the others, then that designer must have had thought of the same thing at the time. It's also reasonable if it happens to be a coincidence.

There are hints that Squall is Laguna's son, but no hints that Seifer is. If Seifer really was Laguna's son, they would have hints in there to make you believe so.

Subtle hints.

And since VIII is subtle, not clear, ambiguous, then it would be stupid of SE to throw words or explict hints into your mouth saying "Laguna is definitely Seifer's father". That would be an extra inconsistency, my friend.

Without hints, anything could be assumed.

Graphics are not hints? What are you talking about?

Even something crazy like Rinoa and Quistis got it on but Rinoa doesn't remember because she was drunk and Quistis forgot because of the GF.

Um, unlikely. Rinoa never looked drunk in the game.

Why don't you just write fan fiction instead of posting your ideas here?

This isn't fan fiction material. I've brought points that actually came from the game and I just happened to connect these dots altogether in order to say that they are brothers. To write a fan fiction, you have to make up something completely... without connecting such dots...

I'm sure they would be very interesting. On that note, this isn't entertaining enough to keep saying why this isn't a good enough argument so I'll just leave it at that.

Then learn how to add me on your ignore list. Very simple to do!