Dynasty Warriors Game Thread: Mafia XX GAME OVER Mafia cockblock the Cult

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

I can back it up with the cop investigation and so can Sima. But oh right, he might be naive. I'll discuss the others on the next day. Today I'm convinced on Meng Huo cause he has ABSOLUTELY nothing to back his claim. At least we have an investigation. Which might or might not be true but at least it has a 50% chance of being so. What does Meng Huo have?

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

But you do have to consider the possibility Guan mgiht be naive. It's to consider him not being naive when you were investiagted and "proclaimed innocent."

Personally I believe his roleclaim to be 100% bogus

Read the thread. Don't mess up the facts.

[[M] D'Anna]

You what screw this

##Stoplynch; Meng Huo

Depending on who is dead at the beginning of the next day I wager it obvious who amongst us is scum

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

Because 1. You fail to consider the fact Guan may be naive. 2. By finding me evil because I claim peasant. :rolleyes:

I'm going to say this once more. It is unlikely that Guan Yu is naive. The main reasoning for this is simple. If there was only town and mafia factions in this game, yes the cop could be naive and the game would not be one sided. However with a cult as well, the town would be at an extreme disadvantage if they had only a naive cop. They would have 2 cops, one naive one proper to put them on an even footing with the other faction. We, however do not have 2 cops. The logical reasoning is that the cop is legit as are his investigation results.

[[M] Elize]

I can back it up with the cop investigation and so can Sima. But oh right, he might be naive. I'll discuss the others on the next day. Today I'm convinced on Meng Huo cause he has ABSOLUTELY nothing to back his claim. At least we have an investigation. Which might or might not be true but at least it has a 50% chance of being so. What does Meng Huo have?

Nothing. I don't have a role claim or a bogus invedtigation on me. If it's 50% possibility of being something to back you up then why should you consider it something to back you up? If it's only half likely to be true it dosen't mean it should be treated as such.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Congrats Cao. You just confirmed my suspicion. You and Meng Huo are cult and that's the end of it. You're even twisting facts, how admirable.

[[M] Elize]

It's perfectly possible for there not to be a standard cop. Unlikely and unfortunate, put possible. Consider the possibilities and don't assume.

Also, who says there can't be a cop amongst us?

[[M] D'Anna]

However with a cult as well, the town would be at an extreme disadvantage if they had only a naive cop. They would have 2 cops, one naive one proper to put them on an even footing with the other faction. We, however do not have 2 cops. The logical reasoning is that the cop is legit as are his investigation results.

You are forgetting one scenario Lu Meng, we were given a double vote townie ie you! So it stands to reason he might be a naive cop or not a cop at all.

[[M] Elize]

Congrats Cao. You just confirmed my suspicion. You and Meng Huo are cult and that's the end of it. You're even twisting facts, how admirable.

This sounds so ridiculous. What facts have Cao or I tiwsted? None. Asolutely none. Infer something else, perhaps. But we didn't twist anything,

And me being with Cao? Why? Because he stopped my lynched. Frankly,t his sounds more like a threat than anything.

[[M] D'Anna]

Also, who says there can't be a cop amongst us?

If that is an indirect roleclaim I will dragon punch you into next week especially since I just stop your lynch!

[[M] Elize]

It's not.

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

However with a cult as well, the town would be at an extreme disadvantage if they had only a naive cop. They would have 2 cops, one naive one proper to put them on an even footing with the other faction. We, however do not have 2 cops. The logical reasoning is that the cop is legit as are his investigation results.

You are forgetting one scenario Lu Meng, we were given a double vote townie ie you! So it stands to reason he might be a naive cop or not a cop at all.

I am considering that fact but it would not be enough to make it a fair game. For that reason, my vote stands. And the way you and Meng are corroborating, I am agreeing with Xiahou. You two are most likely cults.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Anyway discussion is over.

[[M] D'Anna]

Good I don't care what you say X Dun, voting for anybody because they can't back up their roleclaim as peasant is a weak argument. Only me & Lu Meng have confirmed roles & you can forget your so-called cop who has disappeared by the way

[[M] Elize]

Wow, this is just makes you two sound like you're both in cahoots.

Cao Cao stopped my lynch and disagreed with you. So we're BFF's and fellow cultists? That's a stretch.